[00:00:05]
[2. Public Session - 7:30 p.m.]
LET'S RISE FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.I WOULD ALSO LIKE, BEFORE WE START TO CALL FOR A MOMENT OF SILENCE ON TODAY, DAY OF MOURNING.
OKAY, SO ANNE-MARIE, WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE US A [INAUDIBLE] GOD, I CAN'T SPEAK TODAY OF OUR EXECUTIVE MEETING. YES, SURE.
WE MET IN EXECUTIVE SESSION TO DISCUSS THE RECORD OF A PARTICULAR STUDENT AND ALSO DISCUSS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENTS. ALL RIGHT SO NOW LET'S MOVE TO OH, SURE. LET ME JUST.
SO NOW I'M GOING TO HAVE SOME OPENING REMARKS IF YOU NOTICE JACKIE DEANGELIS, OUR PRESIDENT CANNOT BE WITH US TODAY, BUT SHE DID SEND US SOME GREAT NOTES FOR US TO READ. BEFORE I DO READ THAT, I WOULD LIKE TO JUST THANK EVERYBODY FOR COMING BACK.
IT WAS WELL RECEIVED BY THE KIDS, BY THE PARENTS, AND I'M SURE BY THE TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS.
SO IT WAS A GREAT TWO WEEKS OFF AND NOW WE'RE BACK IN 2025.
SO THANK YOU EVERYONE AND HAPPY NEW YEAR AND WELCOME BACK.
SO FROM JACKIE SHE WANTED TO SAY A COUPLE OF WORDS.
UNFORTUNATELY SHE COULDN'T BE HERE DUE TO SOME WORK COMMITMENTS.
BUT I'M GOING TO READ THEM FOR HER.
SO WELCOME BACK FROM THE HOLIDAY.
I HOPE YOU HAD A WONDERFUL TIME WITH FAMILY AND FRIENDS.
SHE'S, YOU KNOW, HER APOLOGIES FOR MISSING THIS MEETING DUE TO HER WORK COMMITMENTS.
WE ARE IN A CRITICAL PERIOD NOW AS A BOARD IS BUDGET SEASON.
WE SPENT TIME AS A BOARD LEARNING HOW TO EVALUATE THE NEEDS BROUGHT FORWARD BY THE DEMOGRAPHIC AND FACILITIES STUDIES THAT WE HAD UNDERTAKEN LAST YEAR, AS WELL AS CONCEPTUAL PLANS THAT WE PUT THAT WERE PUT TOGETHER BY OUR ARCHITECTS WHO HAVE COME TONIGHT AS WELL TO DISCUSS WITH US TONIGHT.
WE WILL ALSO ALIGN ON THE EVALUATION METHOD AND MOVE FORWARD, HOPEFULLY AS A BOARD.
CAPACITY, AGING INFRASTRUCTURE, AND RIGHT SIZING SPACES TO OPTIMIZE THE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT.
WE HAVE BEEN DISCUSSING THOSE NEEDS IN COMMITTEE MEETINGS AND BOARD MEETINGS THROUGHOUT THE FALL.
THERE ALSO HAVE BEEN FACILITY COMMITTEE MEETINGS LAST YEAR TO DISCUSS SOME OF OUR NEEDS IN THE COMING WEEKS, WE'LL BEGIN COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT EFFORTS TO GATHER FEEDBACK AND ENSURE OUR PLANS REFLECT THE NEEDS AND PRIORITIES OF THE COMMUNITY.
SO NOW WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON.
[3. Approval of Minutes]
MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 4TH BUSINESS MEETING.OKAY. ANY ABSTENTIONS? ANY OPPOSED? NO. OKAY, SO NOW MOVING ON TO ADMINISTRATIVE AND COMMITTEE REPORTS.
[4.1 Superintendent's Report]
SO I THINK THAT STARTS WITH ME.AND TONIGHT AS I KNOW THE BOARD IS AWARE BUT JUST FOR THE FOR THE PUBLIC, GIVEN THE SUBSTANTIVE CONVERSATION THAT WE'RE EXPECTING TO HAVE TONIGHT AROUND FACILITIES, WE HAVE GIVEN THE CABINET THE NIGHT OFF ON REPORTS.
[00:05:02]
BUT CERTAINLY IF THE BOARD MEMBERS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR THEM ABOUT ANY, ANY AGENDA ITEMS OR ANYTHING ELSE, YOU'RE MORE THAN WELCOME ALWAYS TO ASK THOSE.SO I AGAIN, I WOULD JUST SAY HAPPY NEW YEAR.
I AS WELL ENJOYED THE TWO WEEKS OFF.
IT'S RARE THAT WE GET THAT KIND OF A BREAK, AND IT REALLY IS RESTORATIVE AND REFRESHING TO HAVE THE TIME TO RELAX, TO BE WITH FRIENDS AND FAMILY, AND TO TAKE A DEEP BREATH AND BE READY FOR THE NEXT PHASE OF THE SCHOOL YEAR.
WE ALREADY ARE STARTING ARE ALREADY STARTING TO THINK ABOUT CALENDAR FOR NEXT YEAR INTERNALLY.
SO YOU CAN EXPECT THAT TO BE COMING FORWARD TO YOU WITHIN THE NEXT MONTHS TIME.
SO WE GO THROUGH A LOT OF PROCESS INTERNALLY, CERTAINLY DRAFTING CALENDARS, USING THE REGULATIONS AND TRYING TO MATCH UP WITH OTHER ENTITIES IN THE, IN THE REGION LIKE BOCES.
SINCE WE HAVE STUDENTS WHO TAKE CLASSES AT OUR BOCES, WE LIKE TO TRY TO ALIGN AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE.
SO JUST KNOW THAT THAT IS IN PROCESS AND IS COMING.
AS THE BOARD IS AWARE, WE'VE BEEN AND I THINK COMMUNITY IS AWARE WE'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR MONITORS FOR MANY POSITIONS, BE IT SPECIAL EDUCATION MONITORS AND SECURITY MONITORS FOR JUST KIND OF ON AN ONGOING BASIS.
THEY ARE UNARMED SECURITY OFFICERS.
I THINK IT'S A REALLY IMPORTANT DETAIL FOR PEOPLE TO KNOW.
I KNOW THERE'S CONCERNS AROUND THAT.
SO I WANTED TO MAKE THAT REALLY CLEAR.
AND WE'LL BE SENDING OUT FOLLOW UP COMMUNICATIONS ABOUT THAT.
IT REALLY GIVES US AN OPPORTUNITY.
WELL, WE ALWAYS WOULD PREFER TO HAVE OUR OWN STAFF IN THESE ROLES.
THAT HAS ALWAYS BEEN OUR STANCE CONTINUES TO BE OUR STANCE.
BUT UNTIL SUCH TIME, WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ALSO ARE ADEQUATELY STAFFED.
SO WE DID HAVE THREE GENTLEMEN JOIN THE THE DISTRICT THIS WEEK.
IN THOSE ROLES, THEY WERE GREETED BY TOM DRAKE, OUR CONSULTANT WHO THEN ORIENTED THEM TO THE SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS, THE SCHOOL SECURITY STAFF THE SCHOOL EXPECTATIONS, OUR SAFETY PLANS AND JUST GENERAL APPROACH ON HOW TO WORK WITH STUDENTS.
THEY AT THIS POINT WE HAVE ONE IS ASSIGNED TO THE FRANKLIN PLACE ENTRANCE AS THE MAIN DUTY POST, AND THE OTHER TWO WILL BE FLOATING ONE IN THE MIDDLE SCHOOL, ONE IN THE HIGH SCHOOL. AND THEIR JOB, AS TOM PUT IT TO ME THIS MORNING, I THOUGHT IT WAS WELL SAID, IS TO BE THE EYES AND EARS TO BE AROUND TO, TO, YOU KNOW, PROVIDE, YOU KNOW, VISIBILITY AND PROVIDE SUPERVISION.
BUT IF THERE ARE ANY ISSUES, THE FIRST MOVE IS TO CALL OUR SCHOOL STAFF, CALL OUR SECURITY STAFF, CALL OUR ADMINISTRATORS, BECAUSE THESE ARE THE FOLKS THAT KNOW OUR KIDS THE BEST. THEY KNOW OUR EXPECTATIONS.
THEY KNOW THEY KNOW A LOT ABOUT OUR STUDENTS THAT OUTSIDE SECURITY STAFF MAY NOT BE PRIVY TO.
SO IT'S IMPORTANT TO CALL ON THOSE RESOURCES WHO DO KNOW OUR STUDENTS BEST.
SO THAT'S THE DIRECTION THAT THEY'VE BEEN GIVEN.
AND SO FAR WE IT'S BEEN MET VERY POSITIVELY FROM THE SCHOOL STAFF.
THAT'S THE COMMITMENT IS THEY'RE PROVIDING US SECURITY EVERY DAY.
SO IT GIVES US A TOOL TO PROVIDE SOME CONSISTENCY TO MAKE SURE WE'RE FULLY STAFFED.
SO I'M SURE JIM WILL ADD ANYTHING TO THAT IF NEED BE IF I MISSED ANYTHING.
SPEAKING OF SUCCESS, AND I KNOW I GET SPOILED BECAUSE THIS HAS HAPPENED EVERY YEAR THAT I'VE BEEN IN PELHAM, BUT DO NOT LET THAT BE A DIMINISHED THE THIS ACHIEVEMENT WE JUST FOUND OUT THIS AFTERNOON.
THE MANY OF YOU MAY BE FAMILIAR WITH THE REGENERON SCIENCE TALENT SEARCH COMPETITION.
IT IS ONE OF THE HIGHEST IN THE NATION STUDENT SCIENCE COMPETITIONS.
EVERY YEAR THAT I'VE BEEN IN HERE NOW, INCLUDING THIS YEAR.
WE JUST FOUND OUT TODAY, PELHAM HAS TWO STUDENTS WHO WERE SELECTED IN THE STS COMPETITION.
THAT'S TWO OF THE TOP 300 STUDENTS IN THE COUNTRY.
LET THAT SINK IN FOR A MINUTE.
[00:10:02]
SO THAT IS SOMETHING JUST FOR ALL OF US TO BE PROUD OF.THAT THEN GETS TRANSLATED UP TO MIDDLE SCHOOL OR MRS. BUCKLEY SCOTT, OUR MIDDLE SCHOOL SCIENCE RESEARCH PROGRAM CLUB, STARTED.
YOU KNOW, ALL THOSE SEEDS ARE PLANTED ALONG THE WAY THAT CULMINATE IN A TREMENDOUS, TREMENDOUS PROGRAM AT THE HIGH SCHOOL THAT CONTINUES TO BE AWARDED NOT JUST AT THE LOCAL OR JUST THE STATE LEVEL, BUT NOW AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL.
SO CONGRATULATIONS TO THOSE TWO STUDENTS IN CASE YOU KNOW, YOU MAY KNOW THEM.
MADELINE PECHELLA AND AXEL ROBINSON.
I JUST WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT HOT OFF THE PRESSES NEWS.
WE HAVE BEEN HAVING THESE CONVERSATIONS FOR WELL OVER A YEAR, BUT TONIGHT WE'RE HERE.
AS A FOLLOW UP TO OUR SEPTEMBER 18TH MEETING, FOLKS MAY REMEMBER WE HAD REPRESENTATIVES RUSS DAVIDSON, WALTER HAUSER CAME THEN TO GIVE US THE OVERVIEW OF OUR BUILDING CONDITIONS SURVEY.
THE BOARD HAS BEEN DIGESTING THAT AND WORKING WITH COMMITTEES TO THEN TAKE THAT AND COMBINE WITH THE DEMOGRAPHIC STUDIES AND THE ROOM UTILIZATION REPORT TO PUT TOGETHER SOME POTENTIAL PROJECTS FOR US TO BE EXAMINING.
SO TONIGHT THEY'RE HERE WITH THE FURTHER DEVELOPMENT OF THAT WORK TO PRESENT THAT TO US.
THE BOARD KNOWS THIS. AT OUR LAST MEETING, WE SPENT TIME TOGETHER AS A BOARD LEARNING SOME STRATEGIES FOR COLLABORATIVE DECISION MAKING AND TRAINING ON THE DECISION ANALYSIS PROCESS. AND STARTING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO HOW TO USE THAT TO BEGIN TO MAKE DECISIONS ABOUT THIS MAJOR PROJECT THAT'S IN FRONT OF US.
SO TONIGHT, WHAT WE HOPE TO DO IS HEAR FROM RUSS AND WALTER SOME UPDATED PRESENTATIONS TO HAVE SOME DISCUSSION, QUESTION AND ANSWER TO GO THROUGH THAT DECISION ANALYSIS CRITERIA AND TRY TO REALLY REFINE THAT AND AGREE ON WHAT WE WANT TO BE LOOKING FOR THERE.
AND THEN DEPENDING ON HOW TIME GOES, WE MAY WANT TO START TO LOOK AT ARE THERE ARE THERE ARE OPTIONS THAT WE WANT TO KEEP ON THE TABLE OR THERE ARE OPTIONS THAT SEEM KIND OF OUTSIDE OF WHAT REALLY MAKES SENSE FOR, YOU KNOW, WHAT WE VALUE AS WE GO FORWARD WITH THIS DISCUSSION.
THIS IS REALLY THE START OF DISCUSSION.
WE'RE NOT GOING TO GET TO FINAL DECISION POINTS TONIGHT NECESSARILY.
BUT, LOOK FORWARD TO THIS BEING THE START OF A LOT OF ENGAGEMENT WITH THE BOARD.
AND AS WAS ALREADY SAID, WE'RE GOING TO BE LAYING OUT AN ENGAGEMENT PLAN FOR THE COMMUNITY SO FOLKS WILL KNOW HOW AND WHEN THEY'LL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME AND BE ENGAGED. SO I KNOW ONE OF THE THINGS WE TALKED ABOUT IN OUR ENGAGEMENT COMMITTEE, AND I'LL SAY IT OUT LOUD AND WE'LL MAYBE SAY IT AGAIN TONIGHT.
WE REALLY ENCOURAGE THE COMMUNITY TO PAY ATTENTION THROUGH THESE NEXT COUPLE OF MONTHS.
WE REALLY WANT FOLKS TO GET ENGAGED.
STAY TUNED, BECAUSE THERE REALLY ARE SOME IMPORTANT, BIG, EXCITING, SIGNIFICANT DECISIONS THAT THE DISTRICT IS GOING TO THE BOARD IS GOING TO BE MAKING ON BEHALF OF THE DISTRICT REGARDING FACILITIES THAT WILL HAVE LONG TERM IMPLICATIONS FOR OUR STUDENTS AND OUR TAXPAYERS.
SO WE REALLY INVITE FOLKS TO TUNE IN AND STAY ENGAGED AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE.
WITH THAT, I'M DONE WITH MY REPORT AND I THINK WE CAN PROCEED.
[4.2 Bond Feasibility Update]
PROCEED AND TURN THIS OVER TO OUR GUEST TONIGHT, RUSS DAVIDSON.WALTER HAUSER FROM KGD ARCHITECTS.
AND I JUST CONTINUE TO APPRECIATE OUR APPRECIATE OUR WORK TOGETHER.
JIM AND I AND JOHN CONDON, WHO'S HERE TONIGHT WITH US AS WELL, HAVE HAD MANY MEETINGS AND FOLLOW UP CONVERSATIONS TO REALLY TRY TO MOVE THIS WORK FORWARD AND TO PROVIDE THE INFORMATION THAT THE BOARD IS LOOKING FOR TONIGHT TO HELP US MOVE, HELPING US MOVE TOWARDS DECISIONS.
YOU KNOW, ONE THING I'LL ADD TO THE BOARD? WELL, ONE THING I'LL ADD FOR THE BOARD WHILE THEY'RE WHILE THEY'RE SETTING UP.
PART OF THAT WILL INVOLVE SURVEYING AND PROBABLY SOME WORLD CAFES, TOWN HALLS, ETC.
SO PLEASE BE THINKING ABOUT WHAT KIND OF FEEDBACK IS GOING TO BE VALUABLE TO YOU AS A BOARD THAT YOU WOULD LIKE US TO GATHER THROUGH THE SURVEYS IN PARTICULAR, AND MAYBE THE WORLD CAFES. ONCE WE GET THROUGH THIS TOWARDS THE ON THE OTHER END OF THE EVENING, WE MAY COME BACK AROUND TO THAT QUESTION.
ALL RIGHT. THAT WAS A WONDERFUL INTRODUCTION.
[00:15:09]
HASN'T DONE ONE SINCE 2015.SO IT'S BEEN A LONG TIME COMING FOR THAT UNDERTAKING.
SO THIS IS JUST A GENTLE REMINDER OF OUR MISSION OF WHY WE'RE DOING THIS.
SO, OF COURSE, THE PRIMARY GOAL IS TO KEEP ALL OF THE BUILDINGS IN GOOD WORKING ORDER.
THEY ARE IN GOOD WORKING ORDER, BUT IT DOES REQUIRE AN INVESTMENT OVER TIME.
SO WE HAVE COMPONENTS THAT ARE AGING OUT AND ARE READY FOR REPLACEMENT.
WE'LL TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT IN A MINUTE.
BUT WE ALSO WANT TO MAKE SURE THE BUILDINGS ARE SIZED TO HANDLE.
SO WHEN WE TALK ABOUT BUILDING CAPACITY, THAT'S REALLY A BLEND OF SPACE AND PROGRAM USAGE.
AND THEN AS WE ARE CONSIDERING CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS, WE ARE ALSO ALWAYS THINKING ABOUT WAYS TO BE MORE SUSTAINABLE AND MAKE IMPROVEMENTS IN A RESILIENT, ENERGY FOCUSED WAY. SO YOU'LL SEE THOSE UNDERLYING ALL OF THE THINGS THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THIS EVENING WITH A LITTLE SUMMARY OF THE SEPTEMBER MEETING.
YEAH. SO WE TALKED ABOUT ENROLLMENTS AND CAPACITY ISSUES.
YOU KNOW, THERE THAT WAS A WHOLE SEPARATE STUDY.
BUT I GUESS THE BOTTOM LINE IS THAT YOU REALLY DO HAVE SOME CAPACITY ISSUES AT COLONIAL AND SIWANOY, BUT IT'S FOCUSED MORE ON SUPPORT SPACE AND COMMON AREAS.
YOU ALSO HAVE A LOT OF UNDERSIZED CLASSROOMS AT BOTH COLONIAL AND SIWANOY.
THE BIGGEST CAPACITY ISSUE LONG TERM IS RIGHT HERE AT THE MIDDLE SCHOOL, HIGH SCHOOL CAMPUS.
AND I THINK THAT YOU'VE GOT SOME TIME TO ADDRESS THAT ONE.
AND YOU'RE GOING TO BE FACING A SPACE SQUEEZE IN THE COMBINED MIDDLE HIGH SCHOOL BUILDING CONDITION SURVEY, AS WALT MENTIONED, IDENTIFIED $95.9 MILLION WORTH OF WORK.
AND AGAIN, THAT'S WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO BRING EVERYTHING UP INTO, LIKE, NEW CONDITION.
SO YOU DON'T REALLY HAVE TO DO $94.9 MILLION OF WORK ALL AT ONCE.
BUT ONE OF ONE OF THE SORT OF GLARING CODE COMPLIANCE ISSUE IS ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCES AND AN INTERIOR ACCESSIBLE ROUTE AT THE SIWANOY SCHOOL.
SO, AGAIN, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT WAS CIVIL RIGHTS LEGISLATION PASSED IN 1990 THAT HAS MADE ITS WAY INTO BUILDING CODE SHORTLY THEREAFTER. SO ALL GRACE PERIODS FOR COMPLIANCE ARE LONG PAST.
SO SINCE OUR SEPTEMBER DISCUSSION WITH THE BOARD, WE'VE BEEN HARD AT WORK WITH THE FACILITIES COMMITTEE, AND A LOT HAS HAPPENED IN THE PROGRESSION OF THE CAPITAL PROJECT DEVELOPMENT. FIRST THERE WAS PRIORITIZATION EFFORT WITH THE INFRASTRUCTURE WORK, AS RUSS MENTIONED.
WE'VE IDENTIFIED ABOUT 96 MILLION.
WE'VE ALSO LOOKED AT SOME OTHER OPTIONS RELATED TO INFRASTRUCTURE, SPECIFICALLY AIR CONDITIONING AND THE POSSIBILITY OF ADDING GROUND SOURCE HEAT PUMPS. WE'LL TALK ABOUT THAT IN A LITTLE BIT LATER ON, BUT THOSE TWO ARE LINKED TO A DEGREE.
AND THEN WE'VE EVALUATED SOME OPTIONS FOR ADDITIONS AND ALTERATIONS, REALLY AT ALL THE BUILDINGS OR MOST OF THE BUILDINGS TO INCLUDE A HEAVY FOCUS ON SIWANOY AND THE HIGH SCHOOL, MIDDLE SCHOOL FACILITIES.
AND THEN, OF COURSE, PREPARED BUDGETS FOR ALL OF THOSE.
SO A LOT HAS HAPPENED SINCE THE LAST TIME WE WERE HERE, AND WE'LL GO THROUGH THAT.
SO I ALWAYS GET THE REALLY EXCITING TASK OF TALKING ABOUT THE INFRASTRUCTURE.
AND I'M JUST GOING TO HIGHLIGHT A FEW ELEMENTS.
SO WE REALLY FOCUSED ON HIGH PRIORITY WORK RELATED TO MAINTAINING YOUR BUILDING ENVELOPE.
SO ENVELOPE IS YOUR ROOFS WALLS, WINDOWS.
AND THERE'S A FOCUS THERE ON KEEPING THE WATER OUT.
AND THEN THE OTHER PRIMARY ELEMENT IS HEATING PLANT REPLACEMENTS AND UPGRADES.
UPGRADE, SO JUST HAVE A FEW SAMPLE PICTURES TO SHARE.
THIS IS THE SLATE ROOF AT PROSPECT HILL.
THAT ROOF IS, I BELIEVE, ABOUT 100 YEARS OLD AND IT'S READY TO BE REPLACED.
AND THIS IS AT SIWANOY AS WELL.
IT IS A PICTURE FROM INSIDE A CLASSROOM.
THE WINDOWS APPEAR FOGGY BECAUSE THERE'S CONDENSATION WITHIN THE INSULATED GLAZING UNIT.
[00:20:02]
OH, I'M SORRY PROSPECT. SORRY.AND THE SEALS ON THE INSULATED GLAZING UNITS HAVE FAILED.
THE WINDOWS ALSO ARE IN NEED OF SIGNIFICANT WORK TO MAINTAIN THEIR OPERATION.
AND THE MECHANISMS THAT HELP THE WINDOWS MOVE UP AND DOWN AND COUNTERBALANCE THEM ARE FAILING.
SO THEY'RE VERY DIFFICULT TO DIFFICULT TO OPERATE AT THIS POINT.
THIS IS THE HIGH SCHOOL AND WE'VE, OVER THE COURSE OF YEARS, DONE A LOT OF MASONRY WORK.
BUT WHEN YOU OWN A MASONRY BUILDING, THAT'S KIND OF A LIFETIME COMMITMENT AND THERE IS ONGOING NEED TO CONTINUE TO MAINTAIN THE MASONRY AND BUILDING THE PICTURE ON THE UPPER RIGHT, YOU CAN SEE SOME WATER INFILTRATION COMING OFF THE TOP COPING.
AND THOSE ARE ISSUES THAT JUST CONTINUALLY NEED TO BE ADDRESSED.
SO THAT'S INCLUDED IN THE PRIORITIZED BUILDING CONDITION SURVEY WORK.
AND THEN FINALLY HEATING PLANTS.
THIS IS A RATHER DRAMATIC PICTURE.
THIS IS PROBABLY THE WORST BOILER IN THE DISTRICT.
IT'S CURRENTLY OUT OF SERVICE.
AND THERE ARE ALSO MANY OF THEM ARE STEAM.
AND THIS IS A TIME TO CONSIDER UPGRADING THE BOILERS FROM STEAM TO HYDRONICS.
SO FROM STEAM TO HOT WATER AND THERE'S AN INVOLVED PROCESS IN DOING THAT.
ALL OF THE PIPING NEEDS TO BE REPLACED WHEN WE DO IT.
SO IT'S A LITTLE BIT OF A, YOU KNOW, IT'S A PRETTY SIGNIFICANT UNDERTAKING, BUT.
SO WE'RE GOING TO SHARE SOME NUMBERS WITH YOU IN A SECOND.
BUT I WANT TO TALK FIRST ABOUT WHAT ARE IN THE NUMBERS.
SO THEY INCLUDE DIRECT CONSTRUCTION COSTS DESIGN CONTINGENCY OF 10%.
WE'RE AT A VERY EARLY PHASE OF DEVELOPING BUDGETS.
THAT'S FOR ALL THE THINGS THAT WE KNOW WE'LL HAVE TO DO, BUT WE HAVEN'T THOUGHT OF JUST YET.
A 10% CONSTRUCTION CONTINGENCY AND AN ESCALATION FACTOR.
SO ESCALATION IS REALLY JUST THE INFLATIONARY PRESSURE ON COSTS OVER TIME.
AND HISTORICALLY, THAT'S A 4 TO 6% PER YEAR.
AND SOME OF THE COMPONENTS WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE ARE PROJECTED OUT FIVE YEARS.
SO PROJECT COSTS ARE ALL THE EXPENSES THAT ARE NON BRICK AND MORTAR.
SO ARCHITECTS, CONSTRUCTION MANAGERS ATTORNEYS INSURANCE ETC..
AND WALTER THOSE ARE PRETTY MUCH KIND OF STANDARD.
THESE ARE THESE ARE STANDARD PERCENTAGES.
THE ESCALATION IS BUILT ON A TURNER CONSTRUCTION COST INDEX.
THEY PUBLISH A QUARTERLY REPORT TRACKING INFLATION OF CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS, COSTS AND LABOR.
AND HISTORICALLY, OVER A TEN YEAR WINDOW, IT'S ALMOST ALWAYS AVERAGED 4% FOR THE PAST 25 YEARS.
CONSTRUCTION ESCALATION IS A WHOLE DIFFERENT THING.
AND HAVING JUST LOOKED TODAY FOR ANOTHER PROJECT BETWEEN 2018 AND 2024.
THAT ADDED UP TO 28% ADDITIONAL COST.
AND THEN YOU'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT ANOTHER 20%.
SO IF YOU'RE COMPARING IT TO YOUR LAST BOND, IT'S ABOUT ONE AND A HALF TIMES MORE.
ANY QUESTIONS ON THAT? MAKE SENSE? GREAT.
SO THAT'S REALLY THE BUILDING ENVELOPE COMPONENTS AND THEN HEATING PLANT REPLACEMENTS.
SO YOU'LL NOTICE THERE ARE TWO CATEGORIES RELATED TO HEATING PLANTS.
ONE IS THE STRAIGHT REPLACEMENT OPTION TO REPLACE STEAM WITH STEAM.
AND THE SECOND ONE IS TO UPGRADE TO HYDRONIC HEAT.
SO THAT'S A WATER BASED SYSTEM WHERE WE'RE PUMPING HOT WATER THROUGH THE BUILDING INSTEAD OF STEAM.
THERE ARE A COUPLE OF CONSIDERATIONS TO MAKE THERE.
WE COULD TALK ABOUT IT IN DEPTH IF YOU LIKE, BUT STEAM PLANTS.
STEAM HEAT IS REALLY AN ANTIQUATED SYSTEM.
IT WAS INSTALLED MANY, MANY YEARS AGO.
PARTS ARE INCREASINGLY DIFFICULT TO FIND.
COMPONENTS THAT INTERFACE WITH STEAM ARE INCREASINGLY DIFFICULT TO FIND AND REPLACE, AND IT'S VERY DIFFICULT TO CONTROL AND LESS ENERGY EFFICIENT THAN HYDRONIC HEAT. SO AS THERE ARE SOME OPTIONS WE'RE GONNA TALK ABOUT RELATED TO GEOTHERMAL AND AIR CONDITIONING AS WE CONSIDER MAKING BUILDINGS MORE SOPHISTICATED, EASIER TO OPERATE AND HIGHER PERFORMING.
WE REALLY WANT TO THINK ABOUT UPGRADING TO HYDRONIC HEAT.
THE OTHER COMPONENT IS ABSENT A PIPE REPLACEMENT PROJECT.
[00:25:02]
WITH THE STEAM HEAT, YOU WILL CONTINUE TO FACE PERIODIC REPLACEMENT OF AGING PIPES.SO THAT IS REALLY A THOROUGH UPGRADE OF YOUR HEATING PLANT TO MODERN SYSTEMS, WITH CAPABILITY TO EXPAND OR ADD OPTIONS FOR MORE SUSTAINABLE APPROACHES.
SO YES, JUST TO CONFIRM, THAT NUMBER IS IN ADDITION.
RIGHT. SO IT'S THE HEATING PLANT REPLACEMENT NUMBER PLUS.
YES. THOSE ARE THOSE ARE ADDITIVE COSTS AND ALL IN THOSE NUMBERS AT THE BOTTOM FOR ROOFING WINDOWS MASONRY AND ALL OF THE RECOMMENDED HEATING PLANT WORK IS $54 MILLION.
THIS IS THE RECOMMENDATION FOR THE PRIORITIZED WORK.
ALL RIGHT WALTER, IS THERE ANY POSSIBLE EFFICIENCIES OR SAVINGS? IF I KNOW WE'VE KIND OF ASKED YOU TO LOOK AT THINGS IN BUCKETS, WHICH IS MAYBE NOT THE MOST EFFICIENT, COST EFFICIENT WAY TO DO IT.
IF THE BOARD WERE TO ADD ON THE UPGRADED HYDRAULIC, FOR EXAMPLE.
WOULD THERE BE ANY POTENTIAL SAVINGS IN THERE OR HAS IT ALREADY BEEN ACCOUNTED FOR HERE? BUT MAYBE WHEN WE LOOK AT GEOTHERMAL LATER, IT'S A GOOD QUESTION.
IT'S VERY DIFFICULT TO PIN DOWN RIGHT NOW THE OVERLAP OF THE POTENTIAL ESTIMATES.
SO NEED TO PULL APART WALLS, TAKE CEILINGS DOWN TO REPLACE THE PIPING.
THERE'S POTENTIAL OVERLAP AND EFFICIENCY THAT COULD BE RECLAIMED ONCE THE PROJECT IS DEFINED.
BUT IT'S APPROPRIATE TO BE CONSERVATIVE AT THIS PHASE BECAUSE GENERALLY IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR WORLD, YOU WOULDN'T FIX A BUDGET UNTIL YOU'RE 60 TO 70% DONE WITH DESIGN IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR WORLD, WHERE YOU CAN'T AUTHORIZE FULL DESIGN UNTIL YOU HAVE FUNDING TO BUILD IT.
WE HAVE TO PROJECT COSTS AT ABOUT 2% DESIGN.
SO WE WANT TO BE CONSERVATIVE SO YOU CAN ACHIEVE WHAT YOU CAN GET DONE.
AND THAT WORKED REALLY WELL IN THE 2017 BOND.
AND THAT AUTHORIZATION AUTHORIZATION YOU'RE SPEAKING OF IS A PUBLIC VOTE IS A PUBLIC VOTE RIGHT.
SO WE CAN'T MOVE TO THAT LEVEL OF DETAIL UNTIL THE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT WILL NOT SUPPORT YOU DOING COMPLETE DESIGN UNTIL YOU HAVE VOTER AUTHORIZATION TO BUILD THE PROJECT.
YOU COULD DO A TWO STEP AUTHORIZATION, BUT THAT'S ALMOST NEVER DONE IN NEW YORK STATE.
YEAH. AND I JUST REMEMBER THAT WAS A LARGE SOURCE OF FRUSTRATION FOR A LOT OF THE COMMUNITY, BECAUSE THEY'RE USED TO THE MORE PUBLIC APPROACH AND A LOT OF, EXCUSE ME, A PRIVATE APPROACH. AND WHAT WE DEAL WITH IS MORE CONCEPTUAL THROUGHOUT THIS PROCESS, AND IT'S THE NATURE OF THE PUBLIC BONDING PROCESS.
I THINK THE CONFUSION SOMETIMES LIES IN THE SPECIFICITY, RIGHT.
SO THERE ARE LOTS OF OPTIONS OF HOW THINGS COULD UNFOLD BETWEEN NOW AND WHEN IT'S BUILT.
AND WE NEED TO THINK ABOUT A BAND OF INFLUENCE AT THIS POINT, WITH A NUMBER OF DECISIONS YET TO BE MADE IN THE FUTURE THAT COULD INFLUENCE OUR BUDGET OR OUR COSTS.
I WANT TO TALK ABOUT CAPACITY AND PROGRAM.
SIWANOY IS ALSO THE SAME THING.
DEDICATED CAFETERIA AND UNDERSIZED.
NEED ADDITIONAL FULL SIZE CLASSROOMS. PROSPECT HILL DID GET SOME.
ADDED CAPACITY IN THE LAST BOND AND IT HAS LARGER CLASSROOMS THAN OTHERS.
THERE ARE SOME INAPPROPRIATE CLASSROOMS IN THE BASEMENT THAT HAVE.
MOISTURE PROBLEMS IN THE MIDDLE.
I WOULD ALSO SAY THERE'S SOME ISSUES WITH RENOVATION RELATED TO PRETTY OUTDATED SCIENCE LABS, WHICH APPARENTLY IS NOT AFFECTING YOUR PERFORMANCE BECAUSE OF YOUR AMAZING STUDENTS, BUT THEY REALLY ARE OUTDATED SCIENCE CLASSROOMS AND LABS.
[00:30:08]
AND THEN THERE'S ALWAYS BEEN AN ISSUE WITH THE DISTRICT OFFICE AS LONG AS WE'VE BEEN INVOLVED WITH PELHAM.AND SO IT MIGHT BE WORTH LOOKING AT OPTIONS TO SOLVE THAT PROBLEM AND GET YOU OUT OF RENTAL SPACE IN CONJUNCTION WITH SOME OF THIS OTHER WORK.
JUST TO BE CLEAR, THEY'RE NOT IN ANY SORT OF RANKED OR PRIORITIZED ORDER.
THIS IS JUST THIS IS JUST EVERYTHING THAT IDEALLY WE WOULD DO IF WE WERE ABLE TO.
SO THE HEAVY DARK LINE IS THE PROPERTY LINE THAT INCLUDES THE PELHAMDALE PROPERTY.
AND I THINK IT'S KIND OF INTERESTING IF THIS NEVER WORKS ON THE SCREEN.
BUT IF YOU SEE THIS LINE HERE, THAT RED DASHED LINE IS THE OUTLINE OF THE HUTCH SCHOOL.
THE OUTLINE OF THE RED OUTLINE IS THE OUTLINE OF THE HUTCH SCHOOL.
SO IT SHOWS YOU THAT COLONIAL IS REALLY THE SITE IS CHALLENGED AND THE BUILDING IS CHALLENGED.
THE BLUE AREA COULD BE A TWO AND A HALF STORY ADDITION WITH SIX CLASSROOMS, BUT YOU WOULD ONLY NET FOUR BECAUSE YOU'RE GOING TO TAKE TWO AWAY WHERE YOU CUT THROUGH.
AND WE COULD PUT A CAFETERIA AT THE LOWEST LEVEL IN THAT COURTYARD, AND IT WOULD BE WONDERFUL AND SOLVE A LOT OF PROBLEMS. YOU'D BE ABLE TO EXPAND THE PLAY AREA TO THE 314 PELHAMDALE PROPERTY, BUT THEN YOU WOULD HAVE TO MOVE OUT OF THAT PROPERTY AND FIND A PLACE FOR THOSE DISTRICT OFFICE EMPLOYEES.
AND IT'S NOT AN INEXPENSIVE PROPOSAL.
SO EACH IDEALLY AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL HAS THREE COMMON AREAS AN AUDITORIUM, A CAFETERIA, AND A GYM.
EVEN WHEN YOU BUILT THE HUTCH SCHOOL, YOU SAID THAT'S IDEAL, BUT EXPENSIVE.
SO YOU HAVE A CAFETERIA THAT FUNCTIONS AS AN AUDITORIUM AND YOU HAVE A GYMNASIUM.
COLONIAL AND SIWANOY ONLY HAVE ONE SPACE THAT DOES ALL THREE OF THOSE THINGS.
SO THAT'S THE REAL ISSUE AT BOTH COLONIAL AND SIWANOY.
THEY AT LEAST NEED A SECOND ONE, BECAUSE IF YOU GO TO ANY OF THOSE SCHOOLS, YOU'LL SEE THAT THEY'RE SERVING LUNCH, HOLDING GYM AND ASSEMBLIES IN THE SAME ROOM.
AND THE CUSTODIAL STAFF DOES AN AMAZING JOB OF MOVING TABLES QUICKLY AND HIDING THEM IN VARIOUS CORNERS OF THE BUILDING TO MAKE CAFETERIAS INTO GYMNASIUMS IN ABOUT 15 MINUTES.
BUT IT'S PROBLEMATIC EVEN FOR A SMALL SCHOOL.
SO THIS WOULD SOLVE THE PROBLEM BY THE GYM WOULD THEN BECOME JUST A GYM AND ASSEMBLY SPACE, AND THE CAFETERIA COULD BE A DEDICATED CAFETERIA. ALSO, ADDITIONALLY, WITH THE CLASSROOM ADDITIONS LIKE THIS, THE CORRIDOR WOULD BE SORT OF CIRCULAR, SO IT WOULD ALLEVIATE CONGESTION. IT WOULD MAKE THE SCHOOL SAFER AND EASIER TO GET AROUND BECAUSE YOU'D HAVE TWO WAYS OUT WHEREVER YOU HIT THE CORRIDOR.
THAT'S KIND OF A THEME ACROSS ALL OF OUR OLD SCHOOLS.
YES, BECAUSE THEY WERE DESIGNED, YOU KNOW, 100 YEARS AGO AND YOU DIDN'T HAVE INTERVENTIONISTS AND RESOURCE ROOMS AND ALL THIS, YOU KNOW, OTPT, SO IT WOULD PROVIDE SOME IT WOULD PROVIDE SOME MORE SPACE THERE.
WE SHOWED THAT IN THE EARLIER CAPACITY STUDY GRAPHICALLY, AND THAT IS A VERY STRONG NEED IN, I WOULD SAY, CONTEMPORARY PUBLIC EDUCATION, ACADEMIC INTERVENTION, ENGLISH AS A SECOND LANGUAGE, LEARNING ACCOMMODATIONS.
THE OLDER SCHOOL BUILDINGS HAVE NO SPACE FOR THIS.
SO IT HAPPENS IN HALLWAYS OR FORMER CLOSETS.
AND IT'S A VERY COMMON ISSUE WITH BUILDINGS, THE AGE YOU HAVE, THIS LACK OF SMALL GROUP SPACE.
WE'LL SEE IT LATER. BUT I THINK THAT AFTER TALKING TO THE COMMITTEE AND THE BOARD WHILE THIS IS A GOOD APPROACH, GIVEN THE PRIORITIES OF OTHER LOCATIONS.
[00:35:02]
THERE WAS NO DESIRE TO FURTHER STUDY THE CONCEPT AT COLONIAL.WE ASSIGNED A NUMBER TO IT BY THE METHODS THAT WALTER DESCRIBED, AND IT'S ABOUT AN ALL IN $19 MILLION PROJECT FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION, RENOVATION, EXPANDING THE PLAYGROUND, REMOVING THE.
COULD YOU JUST GO BACK ONE TO THAT PREVIOUS SLIDE? HOW MANY ADDITIONAL CLASSROOMS WOULD THAT FOUR.
YOU ACTUALLY GET SIX NEW FULL SIZED, BUT YOU ONLY ADD FOUR.
AND THEN YOU'D HAVE A NUMBER OF THEM AVAILABLE FOR SMALL GROUP SPACE.
AND THAT $19 MILLION ON THE NEXT SLIDE.
THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE THE STRUCTURAL HVAC.
ANY OF THAT STUFF OR IS THAT INCLUSIVE OF THAT? IS GENERAL CONSTRUCTION RENOVATION ONLY.
BUT THAT'S TO CHERYL'S EARLIER QUESTION, WHICH IS EXCELLENT.
YOU KNOW, IF WE'RE RENOVATING THE EXISTING BUILDING, IS IT A PORTION OF THAT RENOVATION CREDITED TOWARDS PUTTING IN STEAM PIPING? AND YES, THERE MIGHT BE A LITTLE OVERLAP THERE.
RIGHT. SO, SO THE PRICE TAG FOR COLONIAL WOULD BE THE 19 FOR THE EXPANSION OF THE STRUCTURE, PLUS THE ROOFING WINDOWS, MASONRY, THE SEVEN, THE 70807 MINUS ANY KIND OF EFFICIENT MINOR EFFICIENCY YOU WOULD GET IN DOING IT.
IT'S GOING TO BE LESS THAN 5%, IF ANYTHING.
I THINK, YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE I KNOW THAT THE COMMITTEE SPENT SOME TIME THIS AT THE COMMITTEE LEVEL JUST AND I SAY THIS REALLY MORE FOR THE BOARD WHO WASN'T PART OF THE COMMITTEE AND FOR THE PUBLIC DID SPEND QUITE A BIT OF TIME LOOKING AT COLONIAL BECAUSE FOR ALL THE REASONS THAT WE JUST TALKED ABOUT I THINK ONCE WE GO THROUGH THE REST OF THIS, IT'LL BE A LITTLE BIT EASIER TO SEE THAT IN THE GRAND SCHEME WHEN ONE HAS TO PRIORITIZE, GIVEN THE SCALE AND SCOPE OF WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. THAT COLONIAL REALLY IS NOT AS INASMUCH NEED AS SOME OF THE OTHER BUILDINGS.
ARE WE MAKING IT WORK? YES. SO I THINK THAT'S WHAT THE COMMITTEE'S RECOMMENDATION COMING OUT WAS BASED ON.
AND I KNOW A COUPLE OF YOU ARE ON THE FACILITIES COMMITTEE.
IS IT TIGHT? YES. IS IT PERFECT? NO. IS IT ALSO A BLUE RIBBON SCHOOL? YES. SO, LIKE IT SEEMS TO.
AND WE'RE ALSO TALKING PRIORITIES, RIGHT.
NOT THAT THIS MAY NOT BE A PROJECT DOWN THE ROAD, BUT WE CAN'T DO EVERYTHING AT ONCE.
I THANK YOU FOR THAT. YOU REMINDED ME OF A KEY THING THAT I WANTED TO BE CERTAIN TO SHARE.
SO HOW DO WE REALLY PRIORITIZE? IF YOU LOOK BACK AT THE HISTORY OF THE DISTRICT, THERE HAS BEEN A PATTERN OF LOOKING AT WHICH OF THE BUILDINGS NEED THE MOST ATTENTION AND ATTENDING TO THAT.
SO EVEN THE BUILDING WE'RE SITTING AT WAS BUILT 15, 20 YEARS AGO, 20, 20 YEARS AGO, BECAUSE THERE WAS NO MIDDLE SCHOOL AND THERE WAS A NEED FROM AN ENROLLMENT AND PROGRAMMATIC PERSPECTIVE.
SO THAT'S WHY I'M CHECKING MY PHONE.
2010 THERE WAS A MAJOR PROJECT AT COLONIAL, RIGHT? AND THEN 2018, THERE WAS A MAJOR PROJECT AT HUTCHINSON.
AND AGAIN, THAT JUST KIND OF SPEAKS TO COLONIALS KIND OF BEEN IN THE IN THE ROTATION SO FAR.
IT'S TO YOUR POINT, IT'S NOT THE CONDITION IS NOT IMPACTING NEGATIVELY ON STUDENT OUTCOMES.
SO AND THE NEEDS OF THE OTHER SCHOOLS ARE RISING TO THE SURFACE.
I ALSO THINK WHEN IT COMES TO COLONIAL, WE'VE STRATEGICALLY DONE A FEW THINGS LIKE BUYING THE HOUSE THAT IS NEXT DOOR TO GIVE US THE LAND TO ENABLE US TO ONE DAY TO PUT A PROJECT PLAN WITH MORE DETAILS TOGETHER FOR COLONIAL.
[00:40:03]
FOR COLONIAL. NOW, THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT THEY DON'T THEY SHOULDN'T GET ALL THE, YOU KNOW, ALL THE INFRASTRUCTURE NEEDS TAKEN CARE OF BECAUSE WE DO NEED TO DO THOSE.BUT IN TERMS OF ADDITIONS AND OTHER THINGS, I THINK WE MAY HAVE TO FOCUS OUR, YOU KNOW, OUR NEEDS TODAY IN OTHER SCHOOLS. BUT I THINK FROM A STRATEGIC AND LONG TERM PERSPECTIVE, I THINK COLONIAL IS SET UP VERY WELL BECAUSE THE BOARD, WHO WAS HERE BACK IN 2019, WAS VERY STRATEGIC, AND BUYING THAT PROPERTY RIGHT NEXT DOOR TO ALLOW FOR ONE DAY IN THE FUTURE TO BE USED FOR, AGAIN, AN ADDITION OR ANY OTHER WAYS WE COULD SEE FIT. AND WHAT WAS ADDED ON.
WAS IT 2010? WAS IT A LIBRARY? YEAH, THE LIBRARY.
AND THAT WAS TWO CLASSROOMS AND AN ELEVATOR AND AN ELEVATOR.
THAT BUILD THE ADA WORK WAS DONE IN THAT BUILDING.
PROSPECT HILL GOT THE ELEVATOR IN YOUR LAST BOND.
THAT'S RIGHT. I DID LEAVE THAT OUT OF THE PROJECT.
IT WAS A IT WAS A MINOR, MAJOR PROJECT.
HOW'S THAT SOUND? RIGHT. IT WAS GOING TO BE AN ELEVATOR AND A SECURITY VESTIBULE AND TWO CLASSROOMS, A CLASSROOM AND TWO SGIS LATER.
THAT'S RIGHT. FOR THE SAME BUDGET.
IT WAS DONE. YEAH. RUSS LEARNED A LOT ABOUT ME IN THAT WORK TOGETHER.
I COULD BE A LITTLE DILIGENT WHEN I WANT SOMETHING.
I'VE HAD TWO KIDS GO THROUGH COLONIAL.
I HAVE A THIRD KID IN SECOND GRADE IN THE GREAT HOUSE.
SO I'M A, YOU KNOW, A MEMBER OF THE I'M A COLONIAL LOYALIST.
BUT ARE SOME OF THE OTHER BUILDINGS I THINK WE'RE ABOUT TO SEE LESS PERFECT? YES. AND THIS IS ABOUT MAKING TOUGH CHOICES SO.
SO, SPEAKING OF LESS PERFECT SIWANOY.
IT'S A LOVELY BUILDING IN A NICE NEIGHBORHOOD.
SO WE HAVE DEVELOPED FOUR OPTIONS FOR SIWANOY A, B, C, AND D, AND THE OPTION A IS HOW LITTLE CAN WE DO TO THE BUILDING TO GET AN ELEVATOR IN THERE AND REPLACE THE CLASSROOMS THAT ARE DISPLACED BY THE ELEVATOR? SO SIWANOY HAS A CENTRAL RECTANGULAR BUILDING WHICH WE CALL THE ORIGINAL BUILDING, WHICH WAS BUILT 1 OR 2 YEARS BEFORE.
THE NEW WINGS, WHICH ARE ON THE ANGLE, AND THE NEW WINGS ARE ALMOST 100 YEARS OLD NOW.
SO THERE'S NOTHING BEEN DONE TO THIS BUILDING FROM ADDITIONAL SPACE WISE SINCE THE 20S.
AND MAY I SORRY TO INTERJECT AND INTERRUPT YOUR FLOW, BUT I THINK I'M RIGHT IN SAYING JUST TO KIND OF SET THE SCENE HERE, THAT OF THE FOUR ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS IN THE DISTRICT. I BELIEVE I'M RIGHT IN SAYING THAT SIWANOY HAS THE LOWEST INSTRUCTIONAL SPACE PER STUDENT AND THE LOWEST INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT SPACE PER STUDENT OF THE FOUR ELEMENTARY.
SO JUST LIKE QUANTITATIVELY ON A SQUARE FOOTAGE PER STUDENT BASIS, IT'S THE LOWEST.
YEAH. YEAH. YOU HAVE CLASSROOMS. YOU HAVE CLASSROOMS IN SIWANOY THAT ARE 680FTĀ², WHERE THE STATE MINIMUM IS 900.
SO WE'RE NOT TALKING A FEW PERCENTAGE HERE.
AND THAT'S THE ONLY PLACE IT CAN REALLY GO BECAUSE YOU HAVE A SPLIT LEVEL CONFIGURATION.
SO THE ELEVATOR NEEDS TO GO WHERE THE FLOORS SPLIT.
SO THERE'S NO NET GAIN IN NUMBER OF INSTRUCTIONAL SPACES, BUT A SIGNIFICANT QUALITATIVE GAIN IN THAT YOU'RE GOING TO GET FOUR RIGHT SIZED FULL CLASSROOMS, INCLUDING KINDERGARTEN ROOMS THAT ARE HAVE PRIVATE TOILETS AND FULL 900FTĀ² PUBLIC TOILETS FOR WHICH ARE ALSO BEING DISPLACED BY THE ELEVATOR.
SO YOU'RE GOING TO GET ADA COMPLIANCE IN A NUMBER OF WAYS.
AND THIS HAS A SECOND STORY THAT TIES IN AND PROVIDES TWO FULL SIZE FIFTH GRADE ROOMS AS WELL.
[00:45:03]
SO IT ALLOWS YOU TO SORT OF RIGHT SIZE A NUMBER OF CLASSROOMS, BUT THERE'S NO NET GAIN IN ASSIGNABLE INSTRUCTIONAL SPACE.THERE IS A NET GAIN IN SMALL GROUP SPACE WHERE THE FORMER UNDERSIZED CLASSROOMS WERE.
WE LEAVE IT UP TO THE BUILDING PRINCIPAL AND THE ADMINISTRATORS TO DECIDE WHAT THEY ARE, WHETHER THEY'RE SPECIAL ED RESOURCE, AND, OR YOU CAN ACTUALLY USE THEM AS 811.
SPECIAL ED ROOMS WHICH YOU HAVE A NEED FOR DISTRICT WIDE.
OR THEY CAN BE. ACADEMIC INTERVENTION, READING SUPPORT OR TESTING ACCOMMODATIONS.
AND I'M GLAD YOU MENTIONED THAT PIECE BECAUSE THAT WAS SOMETHING I WAS GOING TO RAISE AS WELL.
AND WE ALREADY KNOW FROM OUR CPSC, OUR PRESCHOOL SPECIAL EDUCATION NUMBERS THAT WE'RE FORECASTING INCREASED GROWTH IN OUR PROGRAM, OUR 811 PROGRAM AS SOON AS NEXT YEAR.
SO WE DEFINITELY NEED SPACE FOR THOSE SPECIALIZED PROGRAMS. IT WOULD BE WONDERFUL TO USE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD A SPACE FOR THOSE STUDENTS SO THAT THEY CAN BE IN ONE SCHOOL, THROUGH THEIR ENTIRE ELEMENTARY YEARS, IN A SPACE THAT'S DESIGNED FOR THEIR PROGRAM, AND HAS THE SMALL GROUP INSTRUCTION SPACE FOR ALL OF THE SERVICE PROVIDERS, CAN YOU JUST.
WE'VE GOT ONE PART OF THE PROGRAM IN COLONIAL.
WE'VE GOT THE OLDER PART OF THE PROGRAM IN SIWANOY.
SO WE MAY WE COULD THERE'S A LOT UP IN THE AIR, BUT THE NET RESULT OF SOME OF THIS BUILDING PROJECT CONVERSATION WILL ANSWER THAT QUESTION, BECAUSE IT COULD BE THAT WE BUILD SPACE FOR, I'LL CALL IT TWO SECTIONS OR TWO.
WE COULD BUILD FOR TWO CLASSES HERE.
WE COULD BUILD FOR FOUR CLASSES HERE.
BUT I GUESS IT SORT OF OFFERS THE POSSIBILITY OF, LIKE, CONSOLIDATION.
EXACTLY. CURRENTLY THEY SPEND, I'D SAY 3 TO 4 YEARS.
COULD YOU JUST EXPLAIN FOR THE COMMUNITY, FOR ANYONE WHO DOESN'T KNOW WHAT THOSE CLASSROOMS ARE LIKE, WHAT STUDENTS ARE SERVED IN THOSE TO MY SPECIAL ED COLLEAGUE TO GIVE US, SHE'S GOING TO GIVE YOU A MUCH BETTER DESCRIPTION OF WHAT AN 8181 THE STUDENT IN 812 CLASS.
SO THE SMALLER THE RATIO, THE MORE SUPPORT THEY NEED BASED ON THEIR DISABILITIES.
THAT COULD BE STUDENTS THAT ARE NONVERBAL.
THOSE CLASSES HAS A TEACHER, A TEACHING ASSISTANT, AND A MONITOR ALREADY BAKED IN.
BUT THEY ALSO HAVE SOME ADDITIONAL MONITORS FOR STUDENT SAFETY.
RIGHT. SO THOSE ARE THE 812 PROGRAMS IN OUR DISTRICT ARE FOR OUR STUDENTS THAT HAVE THE HIGHEST NEEDS AS FAR AS ACADEMICS BASIC DAILY LIVING SKILLS AND NAVIGATING THE SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT.
MAYBE SINCE YOU'RE ON THE ROLL, COULD YOU ASK MAYBE.
MAYBE. COULD YOU PROVIDE A LITTLE BIT OF COLOR AS TO WHY IT WOULD BE IMPORTANT FOR THIS GROUP OF STUDENTS TO HAVE A CONSISTENT LOCATION FOR THEIR LOWER SCHOOL EXPERIENCE? SO, YOU KNOW, FOR THESE STUDENTS WHO PROBABLY HAVE THE HIGHEST NEEDS DEVELOPMENTALLY THEIR PROGRAMS ARE REALLY BUILT AROUND CONSISTENCY.
[00:50:02]
THEY'RE BUILT AROUND ROUTINE.THEY'RE BUILT AROUND STRUCTURE.
SO WHEN THEY'RE SPENDING LET'S SAY, YOU KNOW, A PERIOD OF TIME IN ONE SCHOOL AND THEN FOR FOURTH GRADE, WE'RE ASKING THEM TO TRANSITION WHERE WE DON'T ASK ANY OF OUR OTHER ELEMENTARY STUDENTS TO TRANSITION.
THAT'S A HIGH EXPECTATION FOR STUDENTS WHO HAVE THE HIGHEST DEVELOPMENTAL NEEDS.
BUT I THINK THE BENEFIT OF HAVING THEM EVENTUALLY IN ONE LOCATION TO HAVE THE SAME EXPERIENCE THAT THEIR GENERAL EDUCATION COUNTERPARTS HAVE IS A GOOD THING FOR THEM DEVELOPMENTALLY.
WHEN THE STUDENTS MAKE THE TRANSITION TO THE SCHOOL IT DOES TEND TO BE SEAMLESS.
SO I THINK THE STAFF DOES A TREMENDOUS JOB.
THE PRINCIPALS DO A GREAT JOB MAKING SURE THAT, YOU KNOW, THEY'RE WELCOME TO ANY NEW ENVIRONMENT.
BUT I THINK, AGAIN, IT GOES BACK TO, YOU KNOW, WE'RE ASKING THE STUDENTS WITH THE HIGHEST NEEDS TO DO SOMETHING THAT WE DON'T ASK OTHER K-5 KIDS TO DO, WHICH IS LEAVE A BUILDING.
RIGHT? KIND OF SMACK IN THE MIDDLE OF, YOU KNOW, THEIR ELEMENTARY PROGRAMING.
AND I THINK RIGHT NOW, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE TO DO THAT BECAUSE OF OUR FACILITY LIMITS.
RIGHT? WE DON'T HAVE WE DON'T HAVE A CHOICE.
YOU KNOW AND THAT'S THE I THIS WOULD BE THE IDEAL IS EXACTLY WHAT TRACY'S ARTICULATED.
AND I THINK BECAUSE WE HAVE THIS OPPORTUNITY, WE HAVE TO REALLY WE HAVE TO BE VERY THOUGHTFUL AND SEE IF WE CAN GIVE STUDENTS THAT POPULATION OF STUDENTS THAT IDEAL EXPERIENCE AND FAMILIES.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR THAT. I THINK THAT WAS AN IMPORTANT THING.
EXPLANATION TO BE SAID OUT LOUD.
AND WHAT YOU MAY NOT HAVE SEEN BEFORE IS WE PUT THIS ON A SITE PLAN SO YOU CAN SEE THAT THIS ANGLED WING WITH THE ADDITIONAL CLASSROOM SPACE AND THE CAFETERIA, WHICH IS THAT ROUNDED SECTION, WOULD FACE THE PLAYGROUND.
HE WOULD GET AN ACCESSIBLE ENTRANCE OFF MANOR LANE WITH SOME OFF STREET HANDICAPPED PARKING, WHICH YOU DON'T HAVE, AND THERE WOULD BE A SECURE SECURITY VESTIBULE THERE, SO YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO DO A BETTER JOB WITH SECURITY, HANDICAPPED PARKING AND A HANDFUL OF VISITOR SPACES, AND THAT THE ADDITION IS REALLY ABOUT THE SAME DISTANCE FROM THE PROPERTY LINE AS YOUR EXISTING BUILDING.
WHAT'S THE GREEN BLOB ON THAT? A RELOCATED PLAYGROUND.
I SEE THE GREEN IS THE PLAYGROUND.
NEXT TO THE GREEN BLOB IS THAT BLACKTOP? THAT'S ASPHALT PLAY AREA AND OBVIOUSLY NOT DESIGNED.
WE'RE JUST TRYING TO SHOW YOU THAT YOU STILL HAVE SOME SPACE OUT THERE.
AND WOULD THAT HAVE TO STAY ASPHALT? OR COULD IT BE GRASS? IT COULD BE WHATEVER. WHATEVER WE WANTED.
WE JUST TURN IT INTO A PURPLE BLOB IF WE WANT TO.
THE RIGHT NOW, IT'S ALL ASPHALT.
THAT WHOLE BACK AREA IN THE OUTDOOR SPACE, THE.
I MEAN, THE OUTDOOR GARDEN REMAINS.
THAT'S OVER TO THE ON THE LEFT SIDE.
THAT OUTDOOR CLASSROOM THAT WAS BUILT RECENTLY IS QUITE NICE.
YEAH. SO JUST IN A WAY OF PLAN AGAIN THE ANGLED WING THIS GETS BUILT SIX CLASSROOMS WHICH ALLOWS YOU TO GET A FULL GRADE LEVEL OUT THERE WHICH IS PRETTY NICE FROM A FUNCTIONAL POINT OF VIEW.
IT LEAVES THE GYM AND AUDITORIUM IS A GYM AND AUDITORIUM.
AND AGAIN YOU NET THE SMALL GROUP SPACE.
JUST BACK ON THE SPECIAL ED THING FOR A LITTLE BIT.
THE SQUARE FEET PER STUDENT FOR SPECIAL ED BECAUSE OF THEIR SPECIAL NEEDS IS DRAMATICALLY HIGHER THAN REGULAR ED STUDENTS, SO EVEN AN 811 CLASSROOM NEEDS TO BE A MINIMUM OF 550FTĀ².
AND AGAIN, YOU HAVE KINDERGARTEN ROOMS THAT ARE 650FTĀ² WITH 22 KIDS IN THEM.
SO AND THEN THE UPPER FLOOR WOULD BE ALL OF THE FIFTH GRADE WITH THE FLAT ROOF, A GREEN ROOF PROBABLY OVER THE CAFETERIA AND ELEVATORS AND LIFTS.
[00:55:04]
IN THE RENOVATION.RIGHT. SO EVERYTHING IN PURPLE WE'RE SHOWING IS RENOVATING THE EXISTING BUILDING.
AND THIS IS SOMETHING THAT CAN BE SORT OF DIALED UP OR DIALED DOWN.
BUT RIGHT NOW WE'RE BUDGETING FOR THE BUILDING ADDITIONS AND RENOVATING YOUR EXISTING BUILDING SO THAT THE WHOLE COMBINED THING WOULD BE SORT OF AS GOOD AS NEW, AS GOOD AS IT CAN BE.
SO THIS WOULD NOT MEAN THAT YOU HAVE TO MOVE STUDENTS OUT OF SIWANOY YOU'D BE ABLE TO GET THIS DONE, MOVE INTO THE ADDITION, DO THE RENOVATIONS OVER TWO SUMMERS AND A PART OF A SCHOOL YEAR.
IF WE GO BACK TO THE BUILDING CONDITION SURVEY AND YOU LOOK AT THE INTERIOR WALLS AND DOORS AND ESPECIALLY SINKS AND CASEWORK DISTRICT WIDE, YOU SEE THINGS THAT YOU WOULD NEVER HAVE IN YOUR HOUSE, RIGHT? BUT THE ROOM IS STILL THE ROOM.
AND, YOU KNOW, EVERYONE DOES A GREAT JOB WITH MAKING DO.
BUT IT AND IT DIDN'T GET IN THE WAY.
AND YOU'VE GOT THINGS AGING OUT NOW THAT ARE SORT OF GETTING IN THE WAY OF INSTRUCTION IN OPTION A, WAS THERE ANY INTERNAL RENOVATION INCLUDED? NO. THANK YOU.
REPLACE THE CLASSROOMS. BUT IT'S STILL A VERY SIGNIFICANT INTERVENTION.
WE HAVE TO BUILD A FOUR CLASSROOM ADDITION TO BASICALLY NOT LOSE CLASSROOMS. AND THE RENOVATION OF THE EXISTING BUILDING IS REALLY RELATED TO STICKING ELEVATORS IN THERE AND RENOVATING CLASSROOMS IN THE ELEVATOR HALLWAYS.
SO THAT'S THE LIMIT OF THE RENOVATION IN OPTION ONE.
ONE DETAIL I RECALL FROM SEEING SIWANOY ON THE FACILITIES TOUR IS IN THE BASEMENT.
DO THOSE IS THAT SOLVABLE AS PART OF THIS PLAN OR IS HE NOT REALLY THEY'RE DOING SOMETHING.
THEY WERE NOT INTENDED AS CLASSROOMS. IF YOU GO BACK TO THE ORIGINAL PLANS, THEY'RE SHOWN AS STORAGE ROOMS. OR MY FAVORITE IS THE BICYCLE ROOM, BECAUSE.
AND THE FRONT DRIVEWAY AT SIWANOY IS LABELED CARRIAGE PATH.
SO YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT SOMETHING THAT WAS DESIGNED WHEN AUTOMOBILES WERE NOT REALLY HEAVILY IN USE.
I PICTURE ONE OF THE BICYCLES WITH THE BIG FRONT WHEEL RUNNING.
PENNY FARTHING IS THE TECHNICAL TERM.
OPTION B. SO OPTION C IS A MORE AGGRESSIVE OPTION, WHICH BASICALLY TAKES OFF BOTH OF THE ANGLED NEW WINGS AND CREATES A LARGE ADDITION PERPENDICULAR TO THE MAIN AREA THAT, YOU KNOW, CAN BE A LITTLE BIT MORE CONTEMPORARY IN THE INSIDE, BUT I THINK CAN BE DESIGNED TO FIT IN ON THE OUTSIDE.
WE WOULDN'T TRY AND MIMIC THE OLDER BUILDING, BUT YOU CAN BE RESPECTFUL TO IT.
AND IN WINDOWS AND MATERIAL SELECTIONS.
AND I THINK IT COULD BE REALLY ATTRACTIVE FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
ALSO, IF YOU CAN SEE THE GRAY ON THE BOTTOM RIGHT OF THE YELLOW ADDITION, THIS ACTUALLY IS NOT AS CLOSE TO THE PROPERTY LINE AS YOUR EXISTING BUILDING. AND WE WOULD USE THAT AREA TO HAVE A SERVICE DRIVE TO SERVE A KITCHEN AND HAVE SOME HANDICAPPED PARKING SPACES OFF OF MANOR LANE. BUT YOU'RE SORT OF NET PLAY SPACE WOULD BE ABOUT THE SAME HERE.
AND THE PHASING PLAN WOULD BE TO TAKE OFF ONE WING, WHICH REALLY TAKES YOUR AUDITORIUM AND ART ROOM OUT OF SERVICE, SO YOU'D HAVE TO GET BY WITHOUT THOSE TWO SPACES.
BUILD THE NEW ADDITION, HAVE THAT USABLE, AND THEN RENOVATE THE REMAINDER OF THE EXISTING BUILDING.
BUT THIS WOULD GET YOU TWO BRAND NEW COMMON AREAS, A CAFETERIA AND A FULL SIZED GYMNASIUM THAT WOULD OPEN DIRECTLY TO THE PLAYGROUND. AND YOU WOULD BUILD EIGHT CLASS, FOUR CLASSROOMS ON THIS LEVEL, SIX ON THIS LEVEL.
SO YOU REALLY GETTING A LOT CLOSER NOW TO HAVING FULL SIZED CLASSROOMS FOR ALL GRADE LEVELS.
AND IT REALLY IS A FAIRLY CLEAN PLAN.
[01:00:04]
AND AGAIN WOULD BE FULLY ACCESSIBLE AND YOU WOULD STILL HAVE THE JUST THE ONE ELEVATOR SO YOU DON'T YOU DON'T TAKE THE CLASSROOM OUT OF SERVICE.ON THE LEFT SIDE OF THE BUILDING, ON TWO LEVELS.
TO CREATE THE SECOND ELEVATOR.
RUSS THE SIZE OF THAT GYMNASIUM.
WHAT IS THAT COMPARABLE TO? IT'S THE HUTCH SIZED GYMNASIUM.
IT'S THE SAME SIZE AS THE MIDDLE SCHOOL.
IT'S A HIGH SCHOOL REGULATION BASKETBALL COURT.
YOU COULD HAVE A SMALLER GYM FOR AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL, BUT OUR EXPERIENCE IS THAT MOST COMMUNITIES REALLY WANT A FULL SIZE GYM. IF YOU'RE GOING TO BUILD ONE RATHER THAN ONE, THAT'S 1800FTĀ² THAT YOU CAN'T PLAY BASKETBALL IN.
AND SORRY, IT'S BESIDES THE GYM, WHICH IS A COMMON AREA, WILL ALSO HAVE A CAFETERIA SLASH MULTI-PURPOSE, MULTI-PURPOSE, I GUESS ROOM WHERE ASSEMBLIES COULD BE HELD OR ASSEMBLIES COULD BE HELD.
SO YOU'RE GOING TO BE ABLE TO GET A LOT OF STUDENTS IN THERE AND LOOSE CHAIRS.
AND YOU'LL GET PROBABLY TWO GRADE LEVELS IN THERE FOR LUNCH.
SO YOU'LL BE ABLE TO SERVE LUNCH IN THREE SEATINGS, WHICH IS WHAT THEY'RE GENERALLY DESIGNED FOR.
WE PUT IT IN THE FRONT OF THE BUILDING, WHICH IS GOOD FROM A SECURITY POINT OF VIEW.
AND WE CAN HAVE A DEDICATED KITCHEN AND DELIVERY AREA OUT OF THE WAY OF EVERYTHING ELSE.
AN ALTERNATIVE WHICH WE CAN EXPLORE WOULD BE TO HAVE THE CAFETERIA FACE THE PLAYGROUND.
BUT THAT MAKES THE KITCHEN ACCESS A LITTLE DIFFICULT.
IT'S GOING TO BE ABOUT THE SAME SIZE IS REALLY ALL THAT MATTERS AT THIS POINT.
WOULD THIS OPTION C OFFSET SOME OF THE OTHER INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THIS ONE SINCE IT'S BRAND NEW.
AND THE COST FOR A HEATING SYSTEM IN THE NEW WING IS BUILT INTO THE PRICE OF THE NEW WING.
SO AGAIN WE'LL, WE'LL RE-ANALYZE THAT ONCE THE SELECTION IS A LITTLE CLOSER.
BUT YOU'D SEE A SIGNIFICANT CHANGE HERE.
AND, YOU KNOW, IT WOULD REALLY FEEL LIKE A NEW BUILDING.
YES. SO OPTION C IS A RENOVATION OF THE EXISTING BUILDING, WHICH WOULD MEAN THE CENTER WOULD BE UNALTERED AND THAT WOULD LEAVE THAT HISTORICAL PIECE OF SIWANOY AS RIGHT AS IS THE AXIAL FRONT ENTRANCE WOULD STILL BE THERE, WHICH IS VERY PROMINENT IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
WHAT YOU'RE GOING TO LOSE IS THE ANGLED WINGS THAT WERE NEW A FEW YEARS LATER.
AND IT WOULD BE A TWO STORY ADDITION.
SO WE WOULD BE AT A NET ADD OF SIX NEW SIX CLASSROOMS, TEN, TEN, TEN CLASSROOMS, TEN.
BUT WE'RE GOING TO NET, I THINK EIGHT.
AND THAT INCLUDES THE NEW SPECIAL EDUCATION SPACES AS WELL.
YOU'VE GOT AN 812 ROOM IN THERE ON THIS UPPER LEVEL AT 550FTĀ², WHICH IS THE STATE MINIMUM.
A FEW OTHER SMALL GROUP SPACES, AN OFFICE.
AND RIGHT NOW THE EXISTING BUILDING HAS THE IS SPLIT TO GRADE.
SO IT'S A HALF STORY UP WHICH WAS COMMON IN THOSE DAYS.
BECAUSE THE STREETS WERE DIRT AND YOU WANTED ALL THE DUST TO NOT GET UP TO THAT UPPER LEVEL.
BUT NOW THAT WE HAVE ADA, YOU REALLY WANT YOUR MAIN FLOOR AT GRADE? SO, AS YOU MENTIONED, KEEPING THAT CENTRAL PART OF SIWANOY.
YOU'VE ALSO MENTIONED, YOU KNOW, IF OPTION C IS SELECTED MAKING THE OUTSIDE OF IT THE ADDITION KIND OF SIMILAR ESTHETICALLY TO BLEND IN WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD, WHICH IS IMPORTANT.
AND I KNOW YOU DID A WONDERFUL JOB AT PROSPECT HILL.
YOU CAN'T TELL THE DIFFERENCE UNTIL YOU GO INTO THAT BUILDING THAT THAT AREA IS BRAND NEW.
SO WOULD THAT BE ALSO KIND OF LIKE SOME OF THE CONCEPTUAL PLANS TO MAKE IT LOOK SIMILARLY? SIMILARLY, WE WOULD LIKE A LITTLE MORE TIME TO LOOK AT THE ARCHITECTURE.
[01:05:02]
AND THANK YOU FOR THE COMPLIMENT ON PROSPECT HILL.I THINK YOU HAD A WONDERFUL ARCHITECT ON YOUR BUILDING COMMITTEE.
WHO? DEMANDED THAT IT BE THAT WAY.
AND WE WERE HAPPY TO COMPLY AND GLAD IT WORKED OUT.
WHEN YOU ADD TO HISTORIC BUILDINGS, THERE'S A COUPLE STRATEGIES.
WHEN YOU DO SOMETHING A LITTLE LARGER, MAYBE LIKE THIS, SOMETIMES IT'S BETTER TO HAVE A LITTLE LINK BETWEEN THEM THAT SEPARATES THEM AND CLEARLY SAYS, THIS IS THE OLD BEAUTIFUL THING. THIS IS A NEW, BEAUTIFUL THING THAT RELATES TO THE OLDER THING.
AND, YOU KNOW, WE COULD GO ON WITH ARCHITECTURAL HISTORY, BUT IF YOU'RE EVER IN BOSTON, LOOK AT THE BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY AND YOU'LL SEE THE OLD MCKIM, MEAD AND WHITE BUILDING AND THE NEW PHILIP JOHNSON BUILDING.
THEY DON'T LOOK LIKE EACH OTHER, BUT IN SIZE AND MATERIAL.
THEY HAVE A CROSSOVER AND THEY FIT TOGETHER BEAUTIFULLY.
AND THAT PROBABLY WOULD BE A BETTER APPROACH WHICH, GIVEN THE SIZE OF THIS ADDITION.
BUT TO BE DETERMINED, I HAVE ONE MORE QUESTION TO ADD REGARDING THE NET DIFFERENCE.
SO THE SGI CLASSROOMS, THOSE ARE THE SMALLER CLASSROOMS. GIVEN OUR CURRENT ENROLLMENT, DOES IT LEAVE ROOM, DOES THIS LEAVE ROOM FOR AN INCREASED ENROLLMENT OR, YOU KNOW, LIKE THAT SORT OF ANTICIPATED GROWTH, OR DOES IT FIT THE CURRENT NEEDS? THESE ARE REALLY ABOUT RIGHT SIZING BASED ON YOUR CURRENT ENROLLMENT.
IF YOU MOVE BACK INTO YOUR BASEMENT, YOU COULD INCREASE ENROLLMENT.
HOW MANY TOTAL CLASS FULL SIZE CLASSROOMS IS THIS OPTION? I'M REMEMBERING WHEN WE WERE SKETCHING THIS UP THAT THE GOAL HERE IS TO HAVE 18 FULL SIZE CLASSROOMS AND SIWANOY.
OKAY, BECAUSE I'M THINKING, YEAH, THAT'S HOW MANY DO MANY DO YOU HAVE TODAY? WELL, I'M JUST THINKING HOW MANY SECTIONS WE HAVE.
GIVE ME TWO SECONDS. I CAN FIND IT.
I THINK WE'VE GOT 13 CLASSES SECTION.
NET CLASSROOMS ADDED, RIGHT? YEAH. YEAH. THIS YEAR WE ARE RUNNING 15 SECTIONS IN THE BUILDING, 16 CLASSES, WHICH IS, I THINK THE BIGGEST WE'VE BEEN.
BUT YOU NEED ART AND MUSIC PLUS ART PLUS MUSIC.
RIGHT. PLUS I THOUGHT IT WAS ABOUT 18 FULL SIZE, 700 SQUARE FOOT ROOMS PLUS SGI SPACE.
IS THERE A LIBRARY IN HERE? BECAUSE ONE OF OUR CURRENT WINGS IS ALSO THE LIBRARY.
PROBABLY. NO, BUT WE CAN WORK ON THAT.
YEAH, YEAH, I KNOW, AS YOU SAID, THIS IS CONCEPTUAL AT THIS POINT.
SO AND I'M GOING TO JUST I SHOULD HAVE SHARED WITH THE BOARD TOO.
BUT WE'RE GOING TO SIT AND TALK ABOUT EXACTLY THOSE KINDS OF THINGS.
WHAT ARE THE KEY BUILDING ELEMENTS THAT REALLY NEED TO BE THERE? YOU KNOW, THE TWO ROOMS FOR THE SPECIAL EDUCATION PROGRAM LIBRARY.
JUST ALL THE DIFFERENT THINGS THAT THE, LIKE, AN ELEMENTARY PRINCIPAL WOULD BE THINKING ABOUT.
IS THAT ALLOWED ITS BUILDING PAST YOUR CAPACITY TODAY? SOMETHING THAT COULD BE DONE WITHIN REASON? YEAH, I THINK HUTCH.
AND WITH US, IT'S GOING TO COST YOU MORE, BUT IT GIVES YOU SOME FLEXIBILITY.
AND I THINK THAT AT HUTCH, WE WERE ONE ROOM THAT WAS SORT OF FLEX, FLEX, FLEX.
AND THEN WHEN IT WAS FINALLY BUILT.
SO WE WILL ALWAYS KEEP THAT IN MIND FOR YOU.
WERE THERE STATE RULES THOUGH I THOUGHT AROUND BUILDING.
YEAH. SO THAT GETS BACK TO YOUR ENROLLMENT PROJECTIONS.
SO IF YOUR ENROLLMENT PROJECTIONS SAY THAT THERE'S GOING TO BE 550 STUDENTS IN THIS BUILDING, AND YOU CLEARLY DESIGN A BUILDING FOR 650, BASICALLY YOU'RE ONLY GOING TO GET AID ON THE 550 AND THE REST IS ON YOUR OWN.
SO IT'S GOING TO IT'S GOING TO IMPACT YOUR AID ABILITY IF YOU OVER BUILD FOR FUTURE FLEXIBILITY.
AND SAME THING WITH THE BIG GYM.
THEY'RE GOING TO SAY YOU DON'T NEED A 3500 SQUARE FOOT GYM IN AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL.
A PLAYROOM FOR AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL IS 1800FTĀ².
[01:10:01]
SIZE, EVEN IF IT AFFECTS THEIR AID ABILITY.BECAUSE IF YOU'RE GOING TO REPLACE A BUILDING ON THE SIWANOY SITE, COMPLETELY TEAR DOWN ALL OF SIWANOY AND BUILD A BUILDING ABOUT THE SIZE OF HUTCH, WHICH IS TWO, TWO AND A HALF STORY BUILDING.
IT WOULD BE THAT RED OUTLINE THAT YOU SEE THERE AND TAKE THE ENTIRE SITE.
YOU'D HAVE LIMITED PLAY AREA IN THE BACK, BUT THAT'S ABOUT AS MUCH FOOTPRINT YOU WOULD NEED IF YOU TAKE DOWN THE EXISTING THREE STORY CENTER CORE AND BUILT A NEW BUILDING, AND THAT GOES ALL THE WAY UP TO THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY AS WELL.
THAT GOES ALL THE WAY UP TO THE FRONT OF THE PROPERTY.
YEAH. AND IT'S A MAJOR CONSTRUCTION PROJECT.
AND WHICH BEGS THE QUESTION IS, WHERE DO THE CHILDREN GO? FOR THE 2 TO 3 YEARS.
SO YOU WOULD NEED TO BUILD A TEMPORARY SCHOOL IF YOU CAN'T RENT ONE, WHICH I DON'T BELIEVE THERE'S ANY IN WALKING DISTANCE THAT WOULD BE SUITABLE. THE THINKING WAS RIGHT OUT HERE YOU COULD PUT A BUNCH OF TEMPORARY CLASSROOMS THAT WOULD FUNCTION AS A TEMPORARY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL.
IT WOULD BE A ONE STORY THING.
IT WOULD USE BASICALLY A MODULAR CLASSROOM.
TRAILERS, TWO TRAILERS PER ROOM TIMES 18 OR 20 TIMES TO GET OFFICES AND SMALL GROUP SPACE IN THERE.
YOU WOULD HAVE TO USE THE GYM AND OR CAFETERIA IN THE MIDDLE SCHOOL OR HIGH SCHOOL.
AND IT WOULD TAKE THAT FIELD OUT OF SERVICE, AND IT'S EXPENSIVE.
THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS A TEMPORARY BUILDING CODE.
THINK ABOUT THINGS LIKE BRINGING ELECTRIC SERVICE TO THE SITE, WATER SERVICE TO THE SITE, SANITARY.
AND EVERY STUDENT WHO IS WALKING THERE WOULD HAVE TO CROSS THAT VERY BUSY INTERSECTION.
AND I KNOW THAT WE I DON'T KNOW IF YOU KNOW THE ANSWER TO THIS, BUT WOULD YOU KNOW WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A BOND REFERENDUM? WOULD RENTAL COSTS FOR SUCH A PORTABLE, PORTABLE CLASSROOM SCHOOL BE ALLOWABLE WITHIN BONDING FUNDING? I THINK IT'S ALLOWABLE, BUT IT'S NOT AFFORDABLE.
SO THE MAJORITY OF THE COST OF THAT WOULD BE ON YOU.
SO WHAT DO WE BUDGET THAT AT? I KNEW THAT QUESTION WAS COMING AND I DON'T I'M NOT TOTALLY CLEAR.
IT'S OVER $10 MILLION TO DO THAT EXERCISE OF TEMPORARY CLASS.
I THINK LAST TIME WE SPOKE I THOUGHT WE WERE TALKING 15.
I THINK THE DIRECT THE DIRECT COST WAS ABOUT $10 MILLION.
RIGHT. SO USING THE SAME METHOD FOR EACH.
THESE ARE THE THESE ARE THE BUDGET COMPARISONS.
SO OPTION A IS SORT OF THE FLOOR OF WHAT YOU WOULD NEED TO DO TO MAKE IT MAKE IT ACCESSIBLE.
AND THEN OPTIONS B AND C ARE STARTING TO GET YOU.
SIGNIFICANT IMPROVEMENTS MOSTLY IN THE RENOVATION OF THE EXISTING BUILDING.
THEN OPTION D EXPENSIVE REPLACEMENT BUILDING AND A LOT OF MONEY SPENT ON A TEMPORARY SCHOOL.
DOES THAT CONCLUDE YOUR SLIDES.
THAT'S SIWANOY. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO THE MIDDLE SCHOOL.
HIGH SCHOOL. SO SO JUST JUST KIND OF TO TO ROUND OUT THE NEW SCHOOL CONVERSATION WE'RE JUST HAVING SO THAT APPROXIMATELY $90 MILLION, 15 OF THAT THEN WOULD BE THEORETICALLY REPRESENT THE COST FOR THE TEMPORARY SCHOOL.
YEAH, INCLUDING THE REMOVAL OF SIWANOY SIWANOY.
AND THAT WOULD BE A BIG CONSTRUCTION PROJECT IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD.
[01:15:02]
I MEAN, I KNOW HUTCH WAS A BIG PROJECT AS WELL, BUT YOU HAD ONE SIDE OF IT WAS A STREET, AND THIS ONE IS SURROUNDED BY RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY AND STREETS.SO BEFORE WE GET ON TO THE HIGH SCHOOL, MIDDLE SCHOOL, I JUST THINK THE ONE BIT THAT WE KIND OF JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE COLLECTIVELY DON'T GLOSS OVER IS, IS THE KIND OF WHY SIWANOY RATHER THAN COLONIAL.
AND I THINK WE TALKED ABOUT IT A BIT, BUT I THINK WE JUST GOT TO I MEAN, THE THREE KIND OF FACTORS FOR ME ARE, NUMBER ONE, THE SQUARE FOOTAGE PER STUDENT IS MORE IN NEED AT SIWANOY THAN AT COLONIAL.
NUMBER TWO, THE ADA COMPLIANCE IS NEEDED AT SIWANOY RATHER THAN COLONIAL.
AND THEN NUMBER THREE IS THE IDEA OF SORT OF CONSOLIDATING POTENTIALLY SPECIAL ED AT SIWANOY THAT WOULD THEN ENABLE YOU TO UNLOCK THAT THE USAGE OF THOSE BASE CLASSROOMS FOR INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT AT COLONIAL.
THOSE ARE THE KIND OF THREE THINGS THAT I THINK ARE KIND OF THE PRIMARY DRIVERS FOR THE DECISION, BUT I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE KIND OF COLLECTIVELY AGREE AND THAT PEOPLE UNDERSTAND WHY WE'RE MAKING THAT THAT CHOICE.
THANKS FOR THAT. WELL, YEAH, I AGREE.
I THINK YOU'VE LAID THAT OUT REALLY CLEARLY AND NICELY.
YEAH, I WOULD I WOULD TOTALLY AGREE WITH THAT.
AND I WOULD JUST ADD EARLY ON POINT OF VIEW, FROM MY PERSPECTIVE, IF YOU LOOK AT THE COST FOR OPTION D SEEMS PRETTY EXTRAORDINARY AS FAR AS AN INVESTMENT GOES. BUT I'M, I'M MY EYES KEEP GOING TO OPTION C BECAUSE IT SEEMS LIKE A REALLY GOOD DIRECTION BECAUSE AGAIN YOU'RE SAVING MONEY ON INPUT.
SO OPTION A JUST FEELS LIKE IT'S NOT IT'S LIKE A TEMPORARY BAND-AID THAT'S REALLY NOT GOING TO ADDRESS THE THINGS THAT WE NEED TO AND THE PRIORITIES THAT WE'RE TRYING TO GET TO. SO JUST THROWING IT OUT THERE TO LIKE, I'M KIND OF REALLY THAT'S WHERE MY KIND OF LEANING IS RIGHT NOW BASED ON THE INFORMATION.
AND IT'S ALWAYS SHOCKING WHEN YOU VISIT SOME OF THE SCHOOLS, WHEN YOU COMPARE THEM.
RIGHT, LIKE IN SOME OF THE CLASSROOM SIZES IN SIWANOY VERSUS COLONIAL VERSUS LIKE SOME OF THE OTHER SCHOOLS WHEN ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU COMPARE IT TO LIKE A BRAND NEW SCHOOL LIKE HUTCHINSON. SO I DO TOTALLY AGREE.
AND I WANT TO REITERATE, WE'RE NOT SAYING I DON'T SEE US NOT ADDRESSING COLONIAL TODAY AS A NO.
IT'S JUST NOT A PRIORITY RIGHT NOW, TODAY.
I THINK WE'RE HEADING IN THE DIRECTION OF AIR CONDITIONING.
I THINK WE'RE HEADING IN THE IN THE DIRECTION OF PROBABLY A NEW ROOF.
DO WE NEED A NEW ROOF FOR COLONIAL? I CAN'T REMEMBER. IS THAT ON THE LIST? NO. OKAY. I THINK THE CUPOLA JUST HAD A LITTLE BIT OF THAT.
A LITTLE BIT OF REPAIR. WELL, OKAY, BUT I THINK FAIR ENOUGH.
BUT I MEAN, FOR QUALITY OF LIFE, BOTH FOR THE TEACHING STAFF AND FOR THE STUDENTS.
CENTRAL AIR CONDITIONING, I THINK IS SOMETHING THAT WOULD BE EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TO EVERYONE.
YEAH. AND JUST I JUST WANT TO SAY I APPRECIATE YOUR TEAM COLONIAL, BUT BEING ABLE TO LOOK AT THE BIGGER PICTURE, BECAUSE THERE ARE MANY COMMUNITY MEMBERS THAT WON'T PERSONALLY BENEFIT WHETHER THEY DON'T HAVE KIDS OR THEY'RE NOT IN IT.
SO I THINK THAT THAT WAS REALLY HELPFUL FOR ME TO HEAR FROM YOU AS LIKE SOMEBODY THAT IS IN THE, IN THAT DISTRICT AND YOUR POINT OF VIEW ON IT, I'M SURE YOU KNOW, EVERYBODY HERE AGREES WE ARE TEAM PELHAM.
AND IF IT BENEFITS ONE SIDE OF THIS COMMUNITY, IT BENEFITS ALL.
YEAH. CAN I ASK A QUESTION TOO.
AND REALLY KIND OF WHAT DARRA SHARED ORIGINALLY IS LEADING TO IT.
A NON-STARTER. FOR ME, D WOULD BE A NON STARTER.
[01:20:04]
BUT I DO THINK A DISRUPTION OF THAT MAGNITUDE OF D WOULD REALLY NOT ONLY DISRUPT THE SIANOWY STUDENT BODY, BUT THEN BRINGING THEM HERE WHERE WE ALREADY KNOW WE HAVE CAPACITY ISSUES WITH THE CAFETERIA, WITH THE SPACE.I MEAN, WE HAD THE CONVERSATION THIS WEEK ABOUT THE DRIVE AT 8:00 IN THE MORNING HERE.
I JUST FEEL LIKE THAT MAGNITUDE OF DISRUPTION FOR THIS COMMUNITY WOULD BE, WELL, A LITTLE TOO MUCH.
AND IT TAKES UP ALL MOST OF THE PROPERTY, RIGHT? RIGHT. IF WITH THAT, THE WAY YOU LAID OUT WHAT THE HUTCH SIZE IS.
YEAH, YEAH. UNLESS YOU'RE GOING TO GO WITH A TALLER BUILD.
AND RIGHT. UNLESS YOU WERE TO GO WITH A TALLER BUILDING.
YEAH, IT WOULD BE OUT OF PLACE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD BECAUSE IT WOULD BE QUITE TALL.
YEAH. AND THIS IS A MULTI-STORY BUILDING.
SO AT TWO STORIES WE'RE DEALING WITH A NON-COMBUSTIBLE NON FIREPROOF NON SPRINKLERED BUILDING.
WHEN WE GO TO THREE STORIES IT'S FULLY FIREPROOFED, FULLY SPRINKLERED.
AND THE ALREADY VERY EXPENSIVE COST GOES UP AGAIN.
WHAT'S THE NET CLASSROOM FOR THE OPTION D? IT'S GOT THE FULL PROGRAM, JUST LIKE, LIKE HUTCH.
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT CONFERENCE ROOMS. THE FULL MODEL PROGRAM THAT WAS DEVELOPED WHEN HUTCH WAS BUILT.
YEAH. SO IT HAS THE MOST FOR SURE.
AND THESE AREN'T APPLES TO APPLES COMPARISONS, BUT IT'S A IT'S A VERY EXPENSIVE PROPOSITION TO BUILD A BRAND NEW BUILDING ON THAT SITE. AND THEN THAT 90 MILLION OR 90 PLUS MILLION, WHAT IS HOW DOES THAT COMPARE TO WHAT HUTCHINSON COST? ABOUT 40.
THERE'S NO TEMPORARY SCHOOL THERE.
RIGHT. SO IT'S REALLY SORT OF THIS THE ESCALATION.
YEAH. HOW LONG DID HUTCH TAKE TO BUILD? TWO. TWO YEARS? YES. WE BENEFITED FROM MANY.
MANY. I WAS JUST GOING TO SAY, THOUGH, TOO.
I MEAN, YOU SAID IT WAS ABOUT TWO AND A AND A HALF YEARS ANTICIPATED FOR THIS.
IS THAT REAL? IS THAT REALISTIC? BECAUSE I KNOW HUTCHINSON BENEFITED FROM A LOT OF DIFFERENT THINGS THAT FAST TRACKED IT.
HUTCH WAS BUILT FASTER THAN YOU TOLD THE COMMUNITY.
YEAH. AND BECAUSE OF THE PANDEMIC, IT WAS THE ONLY POSITIVE THAT CAME OUT OF THE PANDEMIC.
SO THIS COULD POTENTIALLY TAKE ALSO THREE.
REALLY. I DON'T FEEL ANY ENTHUSIASM FOR THIS.
SO I GUESS YEAH, IT'S WELL SAID.
SO I'M HEARING THERE'S ENTHUSIASM AROUND CONTINUING TO LOOK AT OPTIONS B AND C ENTHUSIASM AROUND ENERGY AROUND B AND C BUT NO INTEREST IN PURSUING OPTIONS A OR D ANY FURTHER AT THIS POINT FROM THE BOARD.
SO AGAIN, THE ISSUES YOU'RE FACING HERE ARE SOME CAPACITY ISSUES.
BUT THAT'S NOT AN INSIGNIFICANT NUMBER.
SO I DO THINK YOU NEED TO THINK LONG TERM THAT WITHIN THE SORT OF 7 TO 10 YEAR WINDOW, YOU NEED TO BE ABLE TO HAVE SOME ADDITIONAL SPACE AT THIS CAMPUS FOR INSTRUCTION.
AND IT SEEMS TO BE HIGH SCHOOL AGE STUDENTS.
SO ONE OF THE STRATEGIES WOULD BE TO COULD BE TO BUILD MIDDLE SCHOOL SPACE AND GIVE THE HIGH SCHOOL SPACE THAT'S NOW USED BY MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENTS BACK TO THE HIGH SCHOOL.
SO THERE'S A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT WAYS TO DO THIS.
AND A COUPLE OF CONCEPTS THAT WE LOOKED AT WAS CREATING A CONNECTING ADDITION IN BLUE.
WHICH WOULD SORT OF BE OUT HERE.
SO ON THE LEFT, THAT WOULD KEEP THE BREEZE.
SO MIDDLE SCHOOL WOULD GET THEIR OWN CAFETERIA.
THAT WOULD BE ON THE SECOND FLOOR OF THAT ADDITION.
[01:25:03]
IT WOULD CONTAIN FOUR SCIENCE CLASSROOMS, STATE OF THE ART YOU KNOW, 2000 SQUARE OR 1200 SQUARE FOOT SCIENCE ROOMS WITH PREP SPACE AND SOME ADDITIONAL CLASSROOM SPACE, WHICH WOULD ALLOW YOU TO CONVERT THE SECOND FLOOR OF THE ANNEX TO DISTRICT OFFICE SPACE, WHICH COULD HOLD ALL OF YOUR DISTRICT OFFICE ON ONE FLOOR.AND THAT WOULD MOVE THAT WOULD REQUIRE US TO REPLACE EIGHT CLASSROOMS, WHICH WE WOULD REPLACE ON THE THIRD FLOOR, WHERE THE SCIENCE ROOMS ARE NOW, AND BUILD NEW SCIENCE ROOMS INSTEAD.
BUT IDEALLY WHEN DEALING WITH SCIENCE SPACE, IT'S BETTER TO BUILD FULL SIZE NEW AND ESPECIALLY GIVEN YOUR HISTORY WITH SCIENCE, THE CHANGING DEMANDS ON SCIENCE CURRICULUM, A NEW SCIENCE OR STEM WING, I THINK COULD BE THE REAL SORT OF CAPSTONE OF THE PELHAM LEARNING EXPERIENCE.
SO THIS WOULD REQUIRE A NEW ENTRANCE TO BE IN THIS SORT OF CONNECTOR BETWEEN THE ANNEX AND THE HIGH SCHOOL BUILDING, AND THAT WOULD ALLOW US TO PUT AN ELEVATOR THERE SO THAT VISITORS TO THE DISTRICT OFFICE WOULD COME IN, GO UP TO THE SECOND FLOOR, DO NOT HAVE TO GO THROUGH STUDENT OCCUPIED SPACE.
WE'D BE WE'D BE ABLE TO COORDINATE THAT AND SEPARATE IT, AND YOU'D SOLVE YOUR DISTRICT OFFICE ISSUES, YOUR INCREASED POPULATION ISSUES AND STATE OF THE ART HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE LABS.
SO THIS ALSO HAS A STEM ROOM AND ADDITIONAL SCIENCE ROOMS TO ACCOMMODATE THE ADDITIONAL POPULATION AS WELL. SO THAT'S THE QUICK VERSION OF OPTION A.
OPTION B DOES SOMETHING SIMILARLY, BUT IT DOES NOT MOVE THE DISTRICT OFFICE TO THE ANNEX.
IT DOES TAKE AWAY A SCIENCE ROOM IN THE IN THIS BUILDING, WHICH IS SORT OF BEHIND THE OFFICES, TECHNOLOGY ROOM AND MOVES A PORTION OF THE DISTRICT OFFICE HERE.
YOU WOULD STILL NEED SPACE AT PELHAM DALE AND OR ANOTHER LOCATION.
THIS CONCEPT MOVES THE NEW ENTRANCE TO THE EDGE OF THE HIGH SCHOOL.
SO WE TAKE ONE OF THE HIGH SCHOOL CAFETERIA ROOMS AND CREATE A SORT OF COMMONS OR INFORMAL LEARNING AREA, WHICH YOU WOULD NOT NEED ALL THREE CAFETERIAS. IF WE BUILD ONE FOR THE MIDDLE SCHOOL.
AND THEN THE ADDITION WOULD AGAIN REPLACE ONE OF THE.
THE MIDDLE SCHOOL TECH ROOM WHICH IS S1 NEW HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE LABS AND A STEM ROOM.
AND THEN ON THE UPPER FLOOR OF THE ANNEX, WE WOULD RENOVATE THREE OF THE SCIENCE ROOMS AND REPLACE FOUR OF THE GENERAL CLASSROOM SPACES.
SO IT WOULD ALSO ALLOW YOU WITH A TWO AND A HALF STORY ADDITION, SOME ROOF AREA, WHICH COULD BE FUTURE CLASSROOMS. SO WE COULD DESIGN THAT ROOF AS A FUTURE FLOOR.
SO THAT YOU'D HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE ROOM TO ADD 2 TO 3 ROOMS AT SOME POINT IN THE FUTURE.
FRAMED OUT OPTION A, ABOUT $10 MILLION MORE THAN OPTION B.
AND AGAIN, SORT OF OUR FIRST THOUGHTS.
AND I THINK THAT THERE'S PROBABLY MORE WORK THAT COULD BE DONE ON BOTH APPROACHES.
AND WE THINK THE OPPORTUNITY OF CREATING A SORT OF STEM SCIENCE WING IS EXCITING AND COULD REALLY PROVIDE A GREAT DEAL OF BENEFIT, RATHER THAN JUST TAGGING ON MORE CLASSROOMS AND LEAVING OUTDATED SCIENCE LABS.
SO OPTION A DOES NOT INCLUDE DISTRICT OFFICES.
THAT BE FULL INCLUSION IN THE DISTRICT OFFICE.
THIS WOULD GET YOU COMPLETELY OUT OF RENTAL SPACE.
SO WHICH WOULD BE AN IMPORTANT SAVINGS ON THE BUDGET.
I MEAN, THAT'S SOMETHING TO CONSIDER TOO, AS WE CAN WORK WITH JIM AND YOUR FINANCIAL ADVISORS ON HOW THAT IMPACTS THE COST TO TAXPAYERS, BECAUSE EVEN THOUGH IT'S 10 MILLION MORE ROUGHLY THE IMPACT TO TAXPAYERS WILL NOT BE THE FULL 10 MILLION BECAUSE IT WILL BE OFFSET BY NOT PAYING RENT
[01:30:07]
AT THE SANBORN BUILDING, AND IT WILL LEAVE PELHAMDALE AVAILABLE FOR ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING FOR ADMINISTRATIVE LIKE OFFICES.IS THAT A DOUBLE FUNDABLE, WHATEVER THE WORD IS, THE SHORT ANSWER IS NO.
GOTCHA. IT'S REALLY ONLY A SITUATION WHERE YOU'RE RENOVATING EXISTING BUILDING SPACE.
I SEE. IT'S NOT ABLE TO BUILD NEW DISTRICT OFFICE SPACES.
AND YOU CAN SPEND UP TO THAT AMOUNT.
DO WHATEVER YOU WANT AND IT WILL QUALIFY FOR BUILDING AID.
YOU GET 15 BUILDING AID UNITS FOR THAT.
AND FOR THE DISTRICT OFFICE YOU GET ZERO BUILDING AID UNITS.
SO THAT'S WHY IT'S ADVANTAGEOUS TO DO IT IN RENOVATION.
I HOPE STATE ED'S NOT WATCHING YOUR VIDEO.
I'M SURE THEY HAVE BETTER THINGS TO DO.
THIS MAY BE IRRELEVANT, BUT AS I'M SITTING HERE, I'M REMINDED THAT YOU ACTUALLY HAVE TWO ROOMS IN THIS BUILDING THAT DON'T EXIST, BUT COULD BE, COULD EXIST VERY EASILY THERE AND THERE. SO I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IF THAT'S OF NOTE.
YEAH. WE HAVE BEEN TOLD THAT IT WAS.
THEY WERE DESIGNED AS FUTURE FLOORS.
OUR EXPERIENCE WITH THAT, WHICH WE HAVE SOME EXPERIENCES.
THAT'S A VERY EXPENSIVE ROOM BECAUSE IT'S A THIRD FLOOR ROOM.
LOGISTICS, CRANES, YOU CAN BUILD A IF I WOULD RATHER ADD A BUILDING, A ROOM TO A BUILDING ADDITION.
IT DOES PROVIDE YOU SOME FLEXIBILITY AND WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT AND AN OPTION THAT UTILIZES.
I KNOW ALSO THAT I HEAR A LOT ABOUT THE CAFETERIA AND THE NEED FOR THE CAFETERIA AND SORT OF THE INTERACTION THAT STUDENTS HAVE IN THE CAFETERIA. I JUST WONDER IF YOU CAN SPEAK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE LEVEL OF LIKE, NEED OR BENEFIT OF KIND OF BEING ABLE TO KIND OF BRING THAT INTO THE HIGH SCHOOL.
SO, I MEAN, THAT'S SOMETHING WE'VE TRADITIONALLY STRUGGLED WITH BECAUSE WHEN, WHEN THIS BUILDING WAS BUILT, I THINK THERE WERE SOME RENOVATIONS DONE TO CREATE THE CAFETERIAS AS THEY ARE TODAY, BUT IT IS NOT BIG ENOUGH TO SUPPORT FOOD SERVICE FOR BOTH BUILDINGS.
IT'S BIG ENOUGH FOR THE MIDDLE SCHOOL.
SEVENTH PERIOD BECAUSE CAFETERIA WAS WIDE OPEN.
SEVENTH PERIOD. SO IT HAS MADE A SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE ON THE WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE HALLWAYS AND THE STAIRWELLS, WHICH IS WHAT A LOT OF WHAT PEOPLE WERE HEARING ABOUT IN THE PAST.
AS LONG AS THE WEATHER IS NICE, IT DOESN'T ADDRESS THE NEED.
WHEN IT'S RAINY, WHEN IT'S COLD, WHEN OUR, YOU KNOW, UPPERCLASSMEN DON'T LEAVE THE CAMPUS FOR LUNCH.
SO I THINK THAT THAT WILL ALWAYS BE A PIECE OF NEED.
AND UNLESS WE HAVE MORE OF A CAFETERIA SPACE.
AND AGAIN, THAT'S A PROGRAMMATIC QUALITY OF LIFE, IF YOU CALL IT THAT, TO THINK ABOUT, ARE THERE WAYS THAT WE CAN GIVE THEM MORE OF THAT SPACE TO CONNECT PERSONALLY WHERE THEY'VE GOT A LITTLE BIT MORE AUTONOMY? IT'S WHAT DO WE SAY? IT'S LESS SERIOUS THAN A LIBRARY, MORE SERIOUS THAN A CAFETERIA, SOMETHING THAT COULD BE USED FLEXIBLY AS A LEARNING SPACE.
IF A TEACHER WANTED TO BRING A CLASS DOWN COLLABORATION SPACE.
[01:35:03]
REASONS TO HAVE A SPACE THAT COULD ALSO BE FLEXED TO THAT.THE CYBER ROOM. ON HOT DAYS YOU WILL GET HIGH SCHOOL KIDS IN BECAUSE IT'S AIR CONDITIONED.
BUT THE OTHER SPACE, THEY JUST DON'T WANT TO BE THERE WITH MIDDLE SCHOOL KIDS.
SO YOU KNOW, MAYBE THAT WOULD CHANGE OVER TIME, BUT.
I'LL JUST STOP THERE. I MEAN, IT'S JUST GOOD TO KNOW.
I KNOW IT'S NOT ONE OF THE, YOU KNOW, THERE'S SECURITY ISSUES.
THERE'S THAT, YOU KNOW, THERE'S THE ANNEX.
BUT I JUST WANTED TO HEAR A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE VALUE, YOU KNOW, AND, YOU KNOW, THE SECURITY SIDE, IF THERE EVER WERE A SITUATION WHERE WE DIDN'T WANT KIDS GOING OUT FOR LUNCH FOR, YOU KNOW, A PERIOD OF TIME.
YOU ALSO PROBABLY HEAR FROM YOUR KIDS ABOUT LONG LUNCH LINES AND THINGS LIKE THAT.
THAT ALSO COMES FROM HAVING ALL STUDENTS TRYING TO ACCESS AN UNDERSIZED CAFETERIA.
YEAH. SO IN IN SCENARIOS, IT WOULD ALLOW FOR ALL HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS TO STAY IN FOR LUNCH.
IT WOULD BE A SEPARATE CAFETERIA.
SO THERE WOULD BE ROOM FOR THE ENTIRE HIGH SCHOOL.
SO THAT'S THE PROGRAM CHOICES THAT WE'RE CURRENTLY LOOKING AT FOR THE MIDDLE SCHOOL, HIGH SCHOOL CAMPUS AND THAT WE WANTED TO PIVOT BACK TO SOMETHING. SORRY.
I JUST WANT TO ADD ONE QUICK THOUGHT, BECAUSE JUST LOOKING AT THAT $10 MILLION DIFFERENCE, LIKE THERE'S PROBABLY WOULD WE BE ABLE TO ALSO LOOK AT SORT OF IN BETWEEN AN ROI, YOU KNOW, OF THE RENTAL VERSUS THE NOT LIKE WHAT WOULD BE THE VALUE OVER A PERIOD OF TIME.
I WOULD IMAGINE THAT THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING.
THAT FEELS LIKE A LITTLE BIT IT COULD BE A NO BRAINER FOR THIS.
YOU KNOW, THIS PARTICULAR ONE.
YEAH. SO ARE WE INTERESTED IN CONTINUING TO LOOK AT BOTH OF THESE AS WELL AS LOOK AT EVOLVE THESE IDEAS A LITTLE BIT MORE? I DON'T THINK THERE'S A CLEAR LIKE THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL.
THE LAST CONVERSATION THERE SEEMED TO BE LIKE A TWO CLEAR STANDOUTS FOR THIS DOESN'T FEEL TO ME AS CLEAR OF A, YOU KNOW, BUT AND I ALSO THINK LIKE THERE'S ONLY TWO OPTIONS HERE.
SO IT'S WORTH EXPLORING AND DEVELOPING.
YOU KNOW, EACH OF THESE OPTIONS.
I DO THINK WHEN WE EXPLORE, IF WE KNOW HOW MUCH THE RENTAL SPACE IS TODAY.
YEAH. SO FOR ME, IT MAYBE BECAUSE I AM IN THE FACILITIES COMMITTEE.
YOU KNOW, OPTION ONE IS THE CLEAR WINNER FOR ME BECAUSE IT GIVES US EVERYTHING WE WANT.
PLUS IT ENABLES THE ADMIN SPACE TO MOVE IN, LEAVING SOME SPACE AT COLONIAL TO EVENTUALLY DO WHAT WE NEED TO DO THERE AND REALLY CONSOLIDATING MORE. PLUS, PUTTING AN ELEVATOR IN THAT DIRECTLY GOES INTO THE ADMIN SPACE AND NOT HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE KIDS IN THAT CAFETERIA SPACE.
IT'S NOT A MUST, BUT IT WILL FREE UP THE OTHER CAFETERIAS THAT ARE IN THE HIGH SCHOOL.
HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE IN SANBORN RIGHT NOW ROUGHLY? 13, 14.
VALERIE IS SAYING TO ME, 14 LIKE, LIKE SO MUCH IN LIFE, IT'S LIKE COMES DOWN TO PARKING.
IS THERE LIKE ENOUGH PARKING TO ABSORB, LIKE AN EXTRA 14 CARS, YOU KNOW? WELL, THAT'S ALWAYS AN ISSUE HERE.
WE'D HAVE TO, IF ANY OPPORTUNITIES CAME TO INCREASE PARKING.
WE YOU KNOW, WE DO HAVE A GOOD RELATIONSHIP WITH THE VILLAGE AS WELL TOO.
WE COULD CERTAINLY HAVE SOME CONVERSATIONS AROUND THAT.
WE COULD POTENTIALLY EXPLORE ANOTHER STREET TO ALLOW FOR STREET PARKING.
YEAH, WE DO HAVE WE DO HAVE FOLKS PARKING DOWN AT GLOVER.
ACTUALLY. WE HAVE STAFF THAT PARK AT GLOVER DURING THE SCHOOL DAY, WHICH ISN'T GREAT.
IT'S A NICE WALK AND I MEAN ON A NICE DAY, IT'S A NICE WALK.
SORRY, SORRY. BUT ARE THERE BENEFITS? RIGHT NOW, OUR ADMIN STAFF, WE HAVE, YOU KNOW, YOU GUYS ARE AT SANBORN.
THEN WE HAVE JIM AND HIS TEAM OVER ON PELHAMDALE.
AND SO HAVING ALL OF OUR, LIKE, ALL OF THE, THE STAFF IN ONE BUILDING, THAT WOULD BE A HUGE BENEFIT FOR PRODUCTIVITY OR JUST, YOU KNOW, THERE'S A LOT OF BENEFITS TO THAT FOR THE WORKDAY, FOR THE STAFF TO BEING WITH THE STUDENTS.
LIKE WE WERE ALL ON THIS CAMPUS BEFORE THE CURRENT PROJECTS, AND WE NEEDED THE CLASSROOM SPACE.
SO WE MOVED OFF AND SEPARATED.
SO YEAH, THERE'S DEFINITELY EFFICIENCIES THAT ARE LOST.
[01:40:07]
BUT THE ABILITY TO BE TOGETHER WOULD DEFINITELY MAKE WORK MORE COLLABORATIVE, MORE EFFICIENT.AND ANNE MARIE SAID IT, THE BIG PIECE THAT WE LOST WAS BEING WITH HERE WITH THE STUDENTS.
YEAH. I MEAN, TO ME, I'M GOING TO AGREE WITH NATALIE.
IT SEEMS LIKE THE THAT'S THE DIFFERENCE, RIGHT? LIKE THAT'S THE BIG DIFFERENCE.
AND IT. AND I'M GOING TO ASSUME IT'S ACTUALLY ABSORBED BY THE SAVINGS AND BEING ABLE TO DO THAT.
SO IT SEEMS LIKE THE BENEFITS OF EVERYBODY BEING TOGETHER.
AND IT BENEFITS EVERYBODY THE STUDENTS, THE ADMINISTRATION, THE, YOU KNOW, TO DO THAT.
AND IT'S THAT'S SORT OF WHERE MY MIND IS GOING AS WELL.
I MEAN, LIKE QUICK MATH ON THE RENTAL SAVINGS.
I MEAN, I'M GOING TO BE MAKING THESE NUMBERS UP COMPLETELY MADE UP NUMBERS.
AGAIN, THESE ARE MADE UP NUMBERS.
BUT LIKE IF WE SPEND $500,000 A YEAR IN RENT, WHICH WE PROBABLY DON'T.
SO SPENDING $200,000 A YEAR IN RENT, THAT'S TEN YEARS.
SO IT WOULD TAKE LIKE, WHAT, 20 YEARS TO SAVE THE $10 MILLION OF THE, YOU KNOW, TO MAKE UP THE DIFFERENCE.
BUT SOME OF IT SOME OF IT IS [INAUDIBLE] IT'S NOT IT'S NOT A 1 TO 1, YOU KNOW, SAVINGS RATIO.
BUT LIKE THAT'S SORT OF LIKE ROUGH QUICK LIKE WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT.
LIKE A BALLPARK. I DON'T PUT YOU TOO MUCH ON THE SPOT.
IF YOU'RE NOT COMFORTABLE THAT'S FINE.
BUT IF YOU HAD LIKE A BALLPARK.
HOW MUCH COULD WE BORROW IF WE HAD 200 K AS AN ANNUAL DEBT SERVICE? SO IN THE RANGE FOR BETWEEN 4.65 TO 5.8 MILLION, DEPENDING ON WHAT YOUR TERM IS, WHETHER IT'S A 15 OR A 20 YEAR TERM, DEPENDING ON AID LEVELS.
THERE'S NOT A LOT OF CLARITY ON THAT AT THIS POINT.
SO IT'S DIFFICULT TO REALLY LOCK IN ON A NUMBER.
BUT THAT NUMBER, IF THAT ESTIMATE IS CORRECT, THAT COULD BE HALF THE DIFFERENCE RIGHT THERE.
YEAH, DEFINITELY. I THINK IT'S MORE MATERIAL THAN, YOU KNOW THAN THAT.
YEAH. ALL RIGHT. ANY OTHER THOUGHTS OR GUIDANCE TO GIVE TO THE ARCHITECTS ON THIS BEFORE WE MOVE ON TO THE LAST PIECES? I THINK IT'S WORTH EXPLORING BOTH OF THEM, BUT I GUESS MY INITIAL REACTION GIVEN ALL THE OTHER BIG NUMBERS THAT WE'VE SEEN, I DON'T KNOW, THIS LIKE INCREMENTAL 10 MILLION DOESN'T FEEL LIKE A USE OF THE NEXT 10 MILLION COMPARED TO. SIWANOY LIKE FOR $7 MILLION, YOU CAN HAVE A TWO THIRDS NEW SCHOOL COMPARED TO LIKE RENOVATING THE EXISTING ANNEX.
THAT FEELS LIKE A LOT MORE BANG FOR YOUR BUCK THAN GETTING, YOU KNOW, MOVING THE DISTRICT OFFICES IN AND SOME OTHER INCREMENTAL THINGS AT THE HIGH SCHOOL.
YEAH, I THINK TO THAT POINT IN MY MIND, WE'D HAVE TO LOOK AT THE NUMBERS.
IF IT IF IT KIND OF NETS OUT, THEN IT THEN I THINK IT'S A GOOD INVESTMENT.
BUT TO YOUR POINT, IF IT'S 10 MILLION TO SPEND 10 MILLION THEN IT THEN I WOULD SAY NO, NO, BUT I DO IN MY QUICK MIND IN THE MATH, IF YOU THINK ABOUT THEN THE SORT OF LIKE OTHER BENEFIT THAT LITTLE PIECE OF LIKE THE 15% AROUND HAVING THE STAFF TOGETHER, I WOULD IMAGINE IT NEEDS TO NET OUT TO ZERO WITH THOSE OTHER ASPECTS OF IT.
I MEAN, AT THE END OF THE DAY, WE HAVE, YOU KNOW, 55 MILLION OF INFRASTRUCTURE.
MAYBE WE DON'T DO ALL OF IT, BUT, YOU KNOW, THAT'S THE BASELINE.
WE HAVE 35 MILLION OR SO FOR SIWANOY.
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT 35 OR 45 HERE.
AND WE HAVEN'T TALKED ABOUT AIR CONDITIONING YET.
LIKE THE NUMBERS ARE GETTING REALLY BIG AND WE GOT TO THINK ABOUT WHERE.
THEY ARE BIG, WHERE INCREMENTALLY MAYBE IT'S NOT, BUT HERE'S AT LEAST FROM WHERE I VIEW THIS.
[01:45:03]
WE'VE ADDRESSED THE ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES PROBLEM BACK IN 2018, WHEN WE MOVED THE OFFICES OUT BECAUSE WE NEEDED THE SPACE. WE BOUGHT THE HOUSE AND USED IT AS ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICES.WE KNOW WE HAVE A PLAN FOR THAT LAND, SO WE WILL EVENTUALLY HAVE TO FIX THIS PROBLEM.
LIKE THIS IS NOT A I FEEL LIKE WE KEEP KICKING THAT CAN DOWN THE ROAD AND THAT CAN IS GOING TO HIT, AND WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO FIX IT WHETHER WE FIX IT TODAY OR WHETHER WE FIX IT IN FIVE MORE YEARS, IT'S GOING TO HAVE TO BE FIXED.
SO IF IT'S GOING TO COST ME 20 MILLION TO FIGURE OUT WHAT I'M GOING TO DO WITH THE ADMINISTRATIVE SITUATION, AND 5 OR 7 YEARS OR TEN YEARS DOWN THE ROAD VERSUS JUST ADD IT ON.
BECAUSE ANYTHING WE DO WITH COLONIAL RELIES ON GETTING THAT SPACE.
SO I JUST I JUST FEEL LIKE IF WE'RE GOING TO DO SOMETHING, I KEEP THINKING BOLD.
AND YOU ADDRESS THE PROBLEM ONCE AND FOR ALL, BECAUSE I FEEL LIKE WE ARE WE'RE NOT ADDRESSING THAT PROBLEM, AND WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE TO EVERY 6 OR 7 YEARS, EVERY TIME WE TALK ABOUT FACILITIES, WE'RE GOING TO COME BACK TO THE SAME WHERE WE PUT THE ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF.
UNFORTUNATELY, WE'RE LANDLOCKED.
SO WE GOT YEAH, IT'S NOT LIKE WE COULD RENT A LOT OF SPACE FOR CHEAP OR GET FREE SPACE.
I MEAN, I WOULD LOVE TO GET SOME FREE SPACE SOMEWHERE TO CONFIRM.
OH, I'M SORRY. I WAS JUST GOING TO SAY TO CONFIRM THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO IS BASICALLY BRINGING ALL OF THE DISTRICT, ALL OF THE ADMINISTRATORS BACK TO THE MAIN CAMPUS. IS THAT THE MAIN DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THESE TWO? PROGRAMMATICALLY? THAT'S A PRIMARY DIFFERENCE.
THERE'S ALSO THE SIZE OF THE ADDITION, RIGHT? WE HAVE IN OPTION B, WE'VE REDUCED THE SIZE OF THE ADDITIONAL.
BUT SO THERE IS THE POTENTIAL FOR KIND OF A HYBRID BETWEEN THOSE OPTIONS AS WELL.
SO TRYING TO ASSIGN COSTS TO A DRAWING THAT WE'VE PREPARED AND A PROGRAM THAT WE PREPARED.
THERE'S ALSO THE ART OF BUDGET DEVELOPMENT WHICH IS A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT.
THAT'S SAYING WE HAVE X AMOUNT TO SPEND.
AND IN A CASE LIKE THIS THERE MAY BE A DECISION POINT.
HOW CAN WE REWORK THAT A LITTLE BIT FOR 36 MILLION? AND THERE'S ALSO A LITTLE BIT OF ART TO THAT AS WE WEIGH PRIORITIES AS WELL.
BUT DEVELOPING A BUDGET IS EQUALLY AS IMPORTANT TO DEVELOPING A PROGRAM.
BUT IN BOTH CASES, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A NEW CAFETERIA.
YES. YEAH. A NEW MIDDLE SCHOOL CAFETERIA.
BUT OPTION A ALSO HAS REPLACEMENT OF ALL OF THE HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE LABS.
YEAH. AND OPTION B DOESN'T HAS SOME OF THEM.
SOME. OKAY. SO OPTION A GIVES YOU MORE SQUARE FOOTAGE.
YES. WHICH I KNOW I JUST SAID ABOUT FIXING THE FIXING THE PROBLEM.
BUT IF IT ONE DAY WE DO FIND OURSELVES BACK IN.
THOSE COULD POTENTIALLY THEN BE CONVERTED TO YET MORE CLASSROOMS. YES, YOU'VE BEEN KNOWN TO CONVERT THINGS AND CONVERT THEM BACK, RIGHT? YES. SO WOULD IT BE POSSIBLE THEN FOR THE NEXT ROUND TO JUST MAYBE HONE IN A LITTLE BIT MORE, CRUNCH SOME MORE, BECAUSE IT FEELS LIKE IT'S A LITTLE BIT DOWN TO THE NUMBERS GAME.
RIGHT. LIKE, WHAT DO WE THINK THE AID IS GOING TO BE.
WHAT IS THE RENTAL VERSUS THAT SORT OF SOME OF THOSE RETURNS.
CAN WE KIND OF JUST HONE IN ON THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE AND MAYBE IT'LL HELP US ALL KIND OF FEEDBACK.
MY GUESS IS YOU'RE GOING TO SEE AN OPTION C.
OKAY. WHICH IS SOMEWHERE BETWEEN OPTION A WHAT DO WE HAVE OPTIONS.
THIS IS A HUGE DECISION FOR A COMMUNITY.
SO THIS IS WHAT THIS PROCESS IS ABOUT I HOPE WE DON'T GET UP TO OPTION H WHICH IS WHERE WE LANDED.
AND THEN YOU DIDN'T DO ANY OF THEM.
THIS IS A GOOD FEEDBACK, BUT WE DO HAVE A COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS TO TALK ABOUT THERE.
AND THEN IT TURNS OUT THAT IT'S NOT ENOUGH.
SO WE WANT TO TAKE THE TIME TO BE REALLY THOUGHTFUL AGAIN.
ABOUT WHAT? WHAT EXACTLY DO WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE GET IT RIGHT TO, TO NATALIE'S POINT EARLIER ABOUT NEEDING TO FIGURE OUT SPACE FOR PELHAMDALE'S CURRENT USE WHEN EVENTUALLY THERE'S A COLONIAL PROJECT, IS THERE A WAY TO BUILD THIS OR DESIGN THIS SO THAT WHEN PELHAMDALE IS NO LONGER AVAILABLE, WE HAVE AN EASY WAY TO BUILD DISTRICT OFFICES AT THAT POINT.
SO WE DEFER THE COST TO A LATER DATE WHEN IT MAKES SENSE WITH ANOTHER PROJECT.
YES. THERE'S PROBABLY A FISCAL.
[01:50:03]
GOT THAT FLOOR AND MAKE IT DISTRICT OFFICES.WE COULD VERY SIMPLY LEAVE TWO AT THE END AS CLASSROOMS UNTIL SUCH TIME AS YOU MOVE OUT OF PELHAMDALE, WHICH WOULD LOWER YOUR RENOVATION COSTS NOW AND GIVE YOU THE FLEXIBILITY TO DO THAT LATER AND DESIGN AN ADDITION SO WE COULD ADD TWO CLASSROOMS TO THAT ADDITION AT THE TIME YOU DO THAT.
CAN WE MOVE ON TO AIR CONDITIONING? SO APOLOGIES.
ON A DAY LIKE TODAY, IT'S VERY HARD TO THINK ABOUT AIR CONDITIONING.
YES. I'M THINKING ABOUT MY WINDOWS IN MY HOUSE.
AND I WILL NOTE THE GOVERNOR DID SIGN THE BILL OVER THE HOLIDAY BREAK, I BELIEVE.
SO THIS IS REALITY THAT REALITY THAT WE NEED TO DEAL WITH.
YEAH. AND IS THAT ALL CLASSROOMS OR JUST ELEMENTARY I FORGET.
IT'S MORE THAN JUST A PREFERENCE NOW TO A DEGREE.
HOW TO PAY FOR IT? NO FUN THERE.
SO WE'VE PREPARED ESTIMATES FOR WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO PROVIDE AIR CONDITIONING IN EACH BUILDING.
APOLOGIES ON OUR CASCADE HERE.
BUT I'LL JUST READ THEM QUICKLY.
WELL, LET ME SAY THE AIR CONDITIONING IS NOT JUST PROVIDING AN AIR CONDITIONING UNIT.
IT'S ALL OF THE INFRASTRUCTURE ASSOCIATED WITH IT AS WELL.
AND IN MANY CASES IT'S PROVIDING A VENTILATION SYSTEM.
A MECHANICAL VENTILATION SYSTEM WHERE ONE DOES NOT EXIST.
THAT'S CAPABLE OF PROVIDING AIR CONDITIONING AS WELL AS HEATING, BUT IT'S MORE THAN A WINDOW UNIT.
IT'S MORE THAN PUTTING A UNIT ON THE WALL.
SO WE'VE INCLUDED ALL OF THAT IN THESE NUMBERS.
AND IT'S NOT A ONE SYSTEM FITS ALL IN EVERY IN EVERY SPACE.
AND THEN AGAIN, THAT INCLUDES ALL THOSE FACTORS WE TALKED ABOUT BEFORE.
AND THE BIG ONE IS THE HIGH SCHOOL, ABOUT $23 MILLION.
AND THESE ARE BIG SYSTEMS. I WILL JUST GOING BACK TO THE POINT WE WERE TALKING ABOUT EARLIER.
THE AMOUNT OF WORK, PARTICULARLY THAT'S DONE AT SIWANOY THAT WOULD IMPACT THAT NUMBER.
AND THERE IS THE POTENTIAL TO HAVE PRIORITIZATION WITHIN THESE NUMBERS.
SO THESE ARE ALL INTO ALL THE SPACES.
IT MAY BE THAT WE WANT TO LOOK AT DOING PORTIONS OF BUILDINGS.
PARTICULARLY MAYBE AT THE HIGH SCHOOL.
AND YOU KNOW, THE 23 IS A LOT A LOT HERE.
SO THERE IS SOME VARIATION WITHIN THAT AS WELL THAT WE COULD EXPLORE.
WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT THAT FOR A SECOND BEFORE YOU LEAVE AIR CONDITIONING.
REMIND ME, IS THERE A DIFFERENT INCREMENTAL COST IF YOU STAYED WITH STEAM VERSUS HYDRONIC.
THOSE ARE VERY CLOSELY RELATED IN TERMS OF HOW THESE COSTS WOULD PLAY OUT.
THE SIMPLE ANSWER IS I'M NOT SURE.
BUT WHAT I CAN TELL YOU IS IN AIR CONDITIONING SYSTEM WILL TIE IN TO THE HYDRONIC SYSTEM.
THE COMPONENTS WOULD BE OF A FAMILY, AS OPPOSED TO A STEAM SYSTEM, WHICH WOULD BE PROVIDING STEAM HEAT TO SYSTEMS. AND THEN WE'D HAVE A SEPARATE COOLING PLANT THAT WOULD PROVIDE A DIFFERENT MEDIUM TO PROVIDE COOLING TO THE SYSTEMS. SO THE SIMPLE ANSWER IS A HYDROPONIC SYSTEM IS GOING TO INTERACT IN A MUCH NICER WAY WITH THE AIR CONDITIONING THAN A STEAM SYSTEM.
AND IT WOULD INTERACT EVEN BETTER WITH A GEOTHERMAL SYSTEM.
SO I YOU MENTIONED AROUND SORT OF EITHER PIECEMEAL OR CERTAIN PRIORITIES OVER CAN YOU TOP LINE SORT OF WHERE YOU SAW THOSE LIKE REALLY KEY URGENT PRIORITIES VERSUS THE OTHER.
I PROBABLY CAN'T GO INTO DETAIL ABOUT EACH BUILDING, BUT FOR INSTANCE, LET'S SAY AT THE HIGH SCHOOL, IF THERE ARE SPACES THAT HISTORICALLY HAVE GOTTEN, YOU KNOW, BEEN LESS COMFORTABLE WHEN IT'S HOT OUT AND, YOU KNOW, MAYBE WE COULD TALK ABOUT DOING THE UPPER FLOORS OF BUILDINGS THAT WILL HAVE A DRAMATIC EFFECT ON THE BUILDING.
[01:55:05]
NOT ONLY WILL THE COOL AIR KIND OF TRUNDLE DOWN, BUT WE'RE TAKING CARE OF THE PRESUMABLY THE HOTTEST SPACES IN THE BUILDING, AND IT WILL IMPROVE OVERALL COMFORT.IT MAY BE THAT WE DON'T NEED TO AIR CONDITION EVERY SPACE.
THERE ARE CERTAIN CLASSROOMS THAT ARE IMPORTANT AND OTHER AREAS THAT ARE LESS IMPORTANT.
THE TOP ACROSS, ACROSS ALL BUILDINGS.
THAT MAKES SENSE. WITH THE NEW BILL, WAS THERE A TIME LIMIT AS TO WHEN WE WOULD HAVE TO HAVE EVERYTHING DONE? SEPTEMBER. OH YEAH.
WHEN WE OPEN SCHOOL IN SEPTEMBER, WE HAVE TO HAVE A SOLUTION.
SO JIM AND JOHN HAVE BEEN WORKING ALREADY TO THE WIRING I THINK WE'VE TALKED ABOUT HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE IN TWO BUILDINGS, THIRD OF THE ELEMENTARIES, THIRD IS NEXT TO COME. THEY'VE BEEN STUCK.
ALL THREE ARE DONE. THANK YOU.
THREE ELEMENTARIES HAVE BEEN WIRED.
OUR CREW IS BUILT, OUR STAFF IS BUILDING SOME INSTALLATION PIECES TO TRY TO MAKE THEM AS EFFICIENT.
IT LOSES MONEY, YOU KNOW, SO WE DON'T LOSE AS MORE THAN WE NEED TO.
SO YEAH. SO WE STILL HAVE TO GET THE HIGH SCHOOL STILL HAS TO BE WIRED.
BUT THAT WILL THAT WILL POSITION US BY SEPTEMBER TO HAVE ALL THE TOP FLOOR INSTRUCTIONAL SPACES WITH A WINDOW UNIT, A WINDOW UNIT WHICH IS A START TO SOLVING THE PROBLEM.
AND I GUESS THAT'S YOU KNOW, THAT'S THE OTHER QUESTION.
WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT PHASING, TO WHAT DEGREE IS, ARE PEOPLE, YOU KNOW, SATISFIED WITH WINDOW UNITS AS A SOLUTION VERSUS, YOU KNOW, MOVING TO A FULLY AIR CONDITIONED SITUATION? YEAH. SO, YOU KNOW, FOR THE HEATING COMPONENTS, THE AIR CONDITIONING COMPONENTS WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AND REALLY THE NEW ADDITIONS AND RENOVATIONS UNDERLYING ALL OF THAT ARE SUSTAINABLE SYSTEMS AND ENERGY EFFICIENT EQUIPMENT.
WE'D BE LOOKING AT HEAT PUMPS IN ALL OF THOSE SOLUTIONS.
AND I JUST WANT TO SAY AIR CONDITIONING IS A PREREQUISITE TO USE THAT TYPE OF SYSTEM.
IT RELIES ON A BALANCED HEATING AND COOLING LOAD.
BASICALLY USES THE EARTH AS A HEAT SINK TO DISCHARGE OR TAKE HEAT OUT.
IT DOES REQUIRE A BALANCED HEATING AND COOLING LOAD.
SO FOR THOSE OF YOU THAT ARE NOT FAMILIAR WITH GROUND SOURCE HEAT PUMP OR KIND OF REFERRED TO AS GEOTHERMAL THIS IS A SYSTEM THAT USES PIPING TO TURN THE GROUND INTO A HEAT SINK.
THE GROUND TEMPERATURE IS ALWAYS CONSTANT.
THESE SYSTEMS GO DOWN ABOUT JUST UNDER 500FT INTO THE GROUND.
SO IT'S KIND OF LIKE YOUR CAR RADIATOR.
IT PUMPS A REFRIGERANT OR A WATER THROUGH THE PIPING SO THAT IT ALWAYS RETURNS AT A CONSTANT 52 TO 54 DEGREES.
AND THAT ALLOWS THE HEAT PUMP, WATER COOLED OR WATER BASED HEAT PUMP TO EXTRACT OR DISCHARGE HEAT ENERGY INTO THE SYSTEM THROUGHOUT THE YEAR SO IT CAN OPERATE IN A HEATING OR COOLING MODE.
AND WHAT DOES THAT DO? WELL, IT TAKES THE PLACE OF A FOSSIL FUEL FIRED BOILER AND A FOSSIL FUEL FIRED CHILLER PLANT.
SO NOW WE CAN MOVE FROM FOSSIL BASED FUELS TO DO HEATING AND COOLING TO A CLEAN ELECTRIC MODE.
SO IT BASICALLY DISCHARGES OUR FUEL HOOKUP, GETS RID OF OUR BOILERS, AND WE REPLACE IT WITH HEAT PUMP SYSTEMS. BUT THAT DOES REQUIRE A BALANCED HEATING AND COOLING LOAD TO MAKE THAT WORK EFFECTIVELY.
WE DID JUST CONVERT A 1932 MIDDLE SCHOOL.
IT'S ABOUT 170,000FTĀ² FULLY TO GEOTHERMAL.
THIS WAS THEIR ATHLETIC FIELD ADJACENT TO THE BUILDING.
[02:00:03]
AND THEN ONCE THAT INSTALLATION IS COMPLETE, THIS WHOLE SYSTEM LIVES SIX FEET.THE TOPS OF THE WELLS ARE SIX FEET UNDERGROUND, SO ONCE THEY'RE THERE, THEY'RE KIND OF INERT.
AND THE PIPING IS A WELDED PLASTIC PIPE.
IT'LL BE THERE FOR A LONG, LONG TIME.
SO ONCE IT'S INSTALLED, YOU DON'T SEE IT AGAIN, BUT YOU DO NEED SOME REAL ESTATE.
IT JUST ISN'T THE SPACE TO PUT IT.
SO THIS IS NET OF BOILER UPGRADES.
SO THIS IS REALLY THE COST OF THE WELL FIELD AND SWAPPING OUT THE HEAT PUMPS WITH THE BOILERS SO THAT THE HEAT PUMP WORK IN THIS IN THIS ESTIMATE IS NEUTRAL COMPARED TO THE BOILER COST.
SO ASSUMES WE'RE UPGRADING THE BOILERS NO MATTER WHAT.
AND THIS WOULD JUST BE THE ADD FOR THE WELL FIELD.
AND AT THE HIGH SCHOOL IT'S ABOUT $6 MILLION.
SO THESE ARE ADDITIVE COSTS TO THE HEATING AND COOLING SYSTEM, BUT WOULD SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCE OR EVEN REALLY OFFSET ALL YOUR FOSSIL FUEL USAGE FOR HEATING AND COOLING.
AND YOU SAID THESE WOULD HAVE TO BE PAIRED WITH AIR CONDITIONING UPGRADES AS WELL.
YEAH. AND AIR CONDITIONING UPGRADE.
NOT NOT IN PHASES LIKE WE JUST SAID.
BECAUSE IN THAT SCENARIO, THEY'RE GOING TO LOOK AT BOTH HEATING AND COOLING LOADS.
SO PEAK DEMAND ON DEGREE DESIGN DEGREE DAYS.
THERE MAY BE AN OPTION TO DO PARTICULARLY AT THE HIGH SCHOOL.
PROBABLY THE SMALLER BUILDING IS.
NO, IT'S JUST THE WHOLE THING.
AND THESE SYSTEMS COULD GO ON FOREVER.
LIKE A LOT OF TIMES USAGE OF THEM.
YEAH. I MEAN, THE ONES WE'VE INSTALLED AND WE ARE WORKING ON WITH DISTRICTS THAT ARE ALMOST FULLY GEOTHERMAL, LIKE PUTNAM VALLEY CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT, IS ALMOST 100% GEOTHERMAL.
YEAH, ABOUT 25 YEARS AGO, THEY CONVERTED THE HIGH SCHOOL.
THEIR MIDDLE SCHOOL AND PORTION OF THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL WAS DONE ABOUT TEN YEARS AGO.
THIS YEAR THEY'RE GOING TO CONVERT THE WHOLE THING.
THE PUMPS THAT CIRCULATE THE WATER THROUGH THE PIPES WILL BE REPLACED OVER TIME.
BUT THE, YOU KNOW, THE EXPECTED USEFUL LIFE IS 50 PLUS YEARS.
IT'S PROBABLY 2 TO 3 CYCLES OF A HEATING PLANT SYSTEMS. I KNOW, I KNOW, THERE ISN'T TIME NECESSARILY TONIGHT TO GO TOO DEEP INTO IT, BUT I KNOW THAT THERE'S WE'VE IN THE COMMITTEE, WE'VE TALKED ABOUT POTENTIAL GRANT OPPORTUNITIES TO OFFSET COSTS FOR GEOTHERMAL UPGRADES.
YEAH. JUST TO THE EXTENT THEY THANK YOU.
SO IT'S NOT JUST THE $2 MILLION, LET'S SAY, AT TIME WHEN IT WOULD BE ALL THE AIR CONDITIONING, THE HEATING, THAT WHOLE THING NOW BECOMES PART OF THE GEOTHERMAL SYSTEM AND COULD QUALIFY FOR THAT INCENTIVE MONEY.
THANKS. IN ADDITION TO THAT, IS THERE ANY KIND OF LONGITUDINAL, LIKE, SAVINGS, LIKE OUTLOOK, LIKE I WONDER IF THERE IS JUST A WAY TO LOOK AT IT FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE, UNDERSTANDING, LIKE THERE'S NO GUARANTEES OR THERE'S NOTHING TO IT, BUT JUST TO BE ABLE TO LOOK AT IT AS FAR AS JUST THAT, THE COST, THE TAXES.
YEAH. JUST TO BE ABLE TO UNDERSTAND LIKE THIS IS THE FULL INVESTMENT.
[02:05:01]
AND THEN THIS IS SORT OF WHAT, YOU KNOW, LIKE WHAT THOSE RETURNS ARE.YEAH. WE'VE ACTUALLY DONE GEOTHERMAL WELLS ON ONE ENERGY PERFORMANCE PROJECT IN NEW YORK STATE, WHICH HAS TO HAVE A TOTAL UMBRELLA PAYBACK OF 18 YEARS. I CAN TELL YOU THE GEOTHERMAL WELL, FIELDS DIDN'T THEY WEREN'T THE DRIVER ON THE 18 YEAR PAYBACK.
BUT IT'S NOT A 70 YEAR PAYBACK.
AND IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE MUCH LIKE YOUR SLATE ROOFS THAT HAVE BEEN THERE FOR A LONG, LONG TIME, YOU REALIZE THAT PAYBACK KIND OF AFTER THE SECOND LIFE CYCLE OF LIKE A BOILER PLANT, LET'S SAY, OR A FUEL TANK AND, YOU KNOW, NECESSARILY FUEL TANKS, BUT IT'S THE BACK HALF OF THE SYSTEM.
THE PAYBACK REALLY ACCELERATES, WHICH IS GREAT FOR AN INSTITUTIONAL APPROACH.
ANY MORE QUESTIONS ON GEOTHERMAL? SO WE HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF A CASCADE HERE AGAIN.
WELL, I CAN FIX THAT IN A SECOND, BUT WE DID WANT TO TAKE SOME OF THE NUMBERS AND JUST THERE'S A LOT OF NUMBERS OUT HERE AND JUST START TO COMPILE THEM A LITTLE BIT SO WE CAN GET A SENSE OF HOW THEY ADD UP.
ONE SECOND I'LL FIX ALL THESE DOLLAR SIGNS.
I'LL JUST TRY TO FIX IT QUICKLY.
NEED THE JEOPARDY! THEME SONG GOING.
IT'S YOUR ATTENTION TO DETAIL AS AN ARCHITECT.
PREVENTS HIM FROM. HE DOESN'T SAY THAT'S GOOD ENOUGH.
WELL, I HAVE THE TOTAL NUMBERS ARE KIND OF IMPORTANT, RIGHT.
JUST TO FRAME THE CONTEXT HERE.
WELL, IT LOOKS LIKE WE MIGHT BE CLOSE.
WE GOT HIM ON THERE. ALL RIGHT.
FOR SIWANOY IT'S OPTION C AND THE HIGH SCHOOL, IT'S OPTION B.
WE'VE INCLUDED THE AIR CONDITIONING AND GEOTHERMAL.
IT'S A LOT OF MONEY AND THERE'S A LOT TO GO THROUGH HERE.
BUT OBVIOUSLY THERE ARE DIFFERENT WAYS THAT WE CAN CONSIDER PUTTING PROJECTS TOGETHER.
AND IF YOU CAN GIVE US A LITTLE BIT OF FEEDBACK, WE CAN, AS RUSS SAID, GO BACK, REFINE THOSE ESTIMATES, PERHAPS WORK WITH JIM TO PUT TOGETHER SOME ROUGH ESTIMATES ON AFFORDABILITY AND REALLY START TO PROVIDE A LITTLE BIT MORE FEEDBACK OF, YOU KNOW, TO UNDERSTAND THE IMPACT OF ALL THESE PROJECTS.
ANY QUESTIONS ON THE NUMBERS? I KNOW IT WAS A LITTLE PAINFUL TO GET THERE.
ARE YOU LOOKING FOR FEEDBACK TONIGHT, OR IS THIS SOMETHING THAT WE CAN SLEEP ON AND YEAH.
FOR ME, THE THAT BOTTOM ROW WITH THE TOTALS IN IT.
YEAH I, I DON'T REALLY KNOW WHAT TO MAKE OF THOSE NUMBERS WITHOUT UNDERSTANDING THE AID ABILITY, BUT YOU KNOW, THE WHAT THE AID, THE ABILITY, THE TAX IMPACT.
YEAH. WHAT DOES THIS MEAN TO A TAXPAYER? RIGHT. SO WE'LL WORK WITH JIM ON THAT.
I KNOW HE'S DONE SOME HOMEWORK ON IT.
AND I WOULD SAY DO NOT MAKE A DECISION NOW BECAUSE.
[02:10:08]
OPPORTUNITIES COMING UP.SO A DEBT DROP OFF IN A COUPLE OF YEARS THAT WILL GIVE US THE ABILITY TO IN A DEBT NEUTRAL MANNER TO MANNER TO BOND UP TO ABOUT 10 MILLION, AND THEN A FEW YEARS AFTER THAT TO 55. SO THAT'S $65 MILLION THERE.
SO WHICH WOULD THEN GO AGAINST, YOU KNOW, WOULD WOULD BE SOMETHING TO OFFSET THOSE COSTS.
SEEING. AND, YOU KNOW, SEEING AS THE THE END OF THE STORY, IT'S REALLY THE BEGINNING OF THE STORY.
LONG TERM, WHAT WOULD THE PAYBACK POTENTIAL BE ON GEOTHERMAL? AND CERTAINLY, REFINED OPTIONS BASED ON TAKING A COUPLE OFF THE TABLE? AND THE FEEDBACK THAT WAS SHARED, WAS THERE ANY OTHER TAKEAWAYS THAT THE BOARD WAS LOOKING FOR TONIGHT FROM ADMINISTRATION OR FROM THE ARCHITECTS.
IT'S NOT A TAKEAWAY NECESSARILY, BUT I WANT TO.
AND YOU DID SAY IT AT THE BEGINNING, BUT I WANT TO MAKE SURE THE COMMUNITY EITHER WATCHES THE VIDEO.
YEAH. AND I THINK PART OF WHAT YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT WHEN YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT YOU KNOW.
OTHER THINGS TO LOOK AT, I THINK WE TALKED ABOUT WHAT OPTIONS THERE MIGHT BE AT THE HIGH SCHOOL.
THAT MIGHT BE SORT OF INTERMEDIATE APPROACHES BETWEEN THE OPTIONS THERE FOR AIR CONDITIONING.
WHAT INTERMEDIATE OPTIONS THERE MIGHT BE FOR PARTIAL AIR CONDITIONING AND WHAT THAT MIGHT COST.
SOME OF THOSE OTHER STEPS THAT I KNOW MEAN MORE WORK FOR YOU GUYS, BUT WOULD BE HELPFUL FOR US IN.
THINKING ABOUT SPLITTING THE BABY MAYBE ON SOME OF THESE OKAY.
AND MAYBE WE'LL BE TALKING ABOUT THIS NEXT, BUT SORT OF ROUGHLY WHAT IS THE ORDER OF OPERATIONS IN TERMS OF SURVEYS, SOLICITING FEEDBACK, COMMUNICATING THIS IN A SLIGHTLY MORE SUCCINCT FORM? YEAH. WELL SO WE'VE BATTED AROUND SOME IDEAS WE WERE PARTIALLY WAITING TO GET.
WE BEING ALEX AND I TALK ABOUT THIS A LOT.
SO WE'RE GOING TO BE RECONVENING LATER THIS WEEK.
SO WE DO ANTICIPATE WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WHATEVER WE PUT TOGETHER, THAT IT GETS THE BOARD, THE INFORMATION YOU NEED FROM THE COMMUNITY AT THE RIGHT TIME AND THE RIGHT INFORMATION. SO IF THERE IF THERE IS ANYTHING, AS I SAID AT THE BEGINNING, IS THERE ANY INFORMATION YOU WANT US TO START THINKING ABOUT IN THAT SURVEY? AND MAYBE I'LL JUST WE WON'T DO IT TONIGHT, BUT I'LL, YOU KNOW, REACH OUT TO YOU TO YOU ABOUT.
WHAT IS THAT INFORMATION THAT YOU WANT? HEARING WHAT YOU'RE HEARING. KNOWING THE DECISIONS THAT ARE NOW IN FRONT OF YOU.
WHAT INFORMATION WILL BE HELPFUL TO YOU AS A BOARD MEMBER IN OR AS A BOARD AS A WHOLE, YOU KNOW, IN YOUR ROLE AS A MEMBER OF THE BOARD IN MAKING THIS DECISION SO THAT WE CAN SOLICIT THAT EITHER THROUGH SURVEY, IF IT'S A FOCUS GROUP SETTING, WHATEVER IT IS, WE CAN FIGURE OUT THE BEST WAY TO GET THAT.
AND THEN WE'LL ALSO, IF YOU CAN GET US THAT INFORMATION, I'LL SEND YOU A FOLLOW UP NOTE ABOUT THAT.
AND THEN WE'LL TALK ABOUT WHAT DO WE WANT TO DO AS FAR AS ENGAGEMENT SESSIONS, WHETHER IT'S WORLD CAFES, INFO SESSIONS, SURVEYS, AND WE'LL MAP THAT OUT AND COME BACK TO THE BOARD WITH THAT PLAN.
YEAH. AND I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS WOULD BE HELPFUL, AND WE'LL TALK ABOUT AS WE BUILD THIS OUT IS ANNE-MARIE, LIKE YOU SAID, WE WANT EVERYBODY TO PAY ATTENTION, BUT WE HAVE TO LIVE IN THE REALITY LIKE MOST PEOPLE MIGHT NOT BE ABLE TO WATCH THIS ENTIRE THING.
RIGHT. SO AS WE GET OUT THE SURVEYS, AS WE BEGIN TO DO IT, HOW DO WE REALLY.
SHARE THAT MOST IMPORTANT PIECES OF INFORMATION IN A VERY CONDENSED MANNER TO BRING THE COMMUNITY ALONG TO ANSWER THE SURVEYS OR TO DO THAT. BECAUSE THIS IS.
SO ANYWAY, SO I JUST WANTED TO I THINK THAT THAT WOULD BE A GREAT TOOL FOR US TO BUILD IF WE DO LIKE A COMEDY TOUR OR SOMETHING DIFFERENT. DRESS UP AS THE DIFFERENT.
YEAH, DRESS UP AND DO LIKE IMPROV OF LIKE DIFFERENT SCENARIOS.
YEAH, PEOPLE WOULD PAY ATTENTION TO THAT.
I'M GOING TO SUGGEST THE DISCUSSION ABOUT THE CRITERIA FOR THE DECISION ANALYSIS.
[02:15:01]
WE JUST POSTPONED TILL NEXT TIME.IT'S BEEN A REALLY ROBUST CONVERSATION, A LOT OF INFORMATION TO ABSORB.
THANK YOU. I REALLY THANK YOU SO MUCH.
BEAUTIFUL JOB. APPRECIATE THE COLLABORATION.
I KNOW YOU'VE GOT THIS FEEDBACK.
ONCE WE MEET WITH THE ADMINISTRATORS.
I THINK THERE WAS SOME DISCUSSION OF MAYBE HAVING A COMMITTEE MEETING AS WELL.
SO THERE MIGHT BE SOME WORK THAT THE COMMITTEE CAN TAKE ON TO A MEETING NEXT WEEK.
YES. OKAY. GREAT. SO WE GOT THAT JOINT COMMITTEE COMING UP.
HAVE A WONDERFUL NIGHT. WE APPRECIATE IT.
OKAY. ALL RIGHT MOVING ON TO 4.3 BOARD OF EDUCATION COMMITTEE REPORTS.
[4.3 Board of Education Committee Reports]
I THINK WE BAILED ON THOSE.ADVOCACY. ADVOCACY AND ENGAGEMENT YESTERDAY.
SO WE ARE TAKING IT BACK AND REVISITING, READJUSTING, REDOING.
GREAT FEEDBACK, I DO THINK, AND I LOVE THE IDEA OF THE WORLD CAFES.
WE'VE BEEN DOING THEM FOR THE LAST FEW YEARS ON TOPICS THAT REALLY HAVE AFFECTED US.
AND THE COMMUNITY, THEY DO SHOW UP FOR THOSE AND THEY'RE VERY INFORMATIVE AND ALSO SURVEYS.
SO AGAIN, A LOT OF OPTIONS THAT COULD POTENTIALLY HAPPEN FROM THAT COMMITTEE.
SO I THINK WE'RE GOING TO PROBABLY MEET SOONER RATHER THAN LATER AGAIN.
YEAH. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU WANT TO ADD ANYTHING.
NO, I THINK YOU COVERED EVERYTHING.
I'M LIKE, OH, WE DON'T HAVE COMMUNICATIONS COMING FROM THE PUBLIC.
SO MOVING ON TO FINANCIAL REPORTS, CAN WE TAKE THIS AS A CONSENT?
[6.1 Motion to Accept the New York State Education Department's Regionalization Plan]
THIS IS THE ONE WHERE WE GOT THE DIFFERENCE.ACTUALLY, I THINK I'LL KICK THIS PIECE OFF.
I KNOW I SHARED WITH THE BOARD IN THE PAST THE DISTRICT, THE STATE'S REGIONALIZATION EFFORTS.
THE STATE DID PUT OUT A REQUIREMENT FOR DISTRICTS TO SUPERINTENDENTS TO SUBMIT DATA, ALL THANKS TO THE CABINET AND OUR DISTRICT DATA ANALYST WHO HELPED US TO ASSEMBLE THE I THINK IT'S 43 PAGE, 47 PAGE PORTAL OF DATA TO SUBMIT TO THE STATE, WHICH WAS LARGELY MADE UP OF DATA THAT THE STATE ALREADY HAD.
SO IT WAS NOT THE BEST USE OF DISTRICT RESOURCES, BUT THAT WAS WHAT WE WERE REQUIRED TO DO.
AND THEN THE NEXT DAY, THE COMMISSIONER CAME OUT WITH A MEMO BASED ON ALL THE PRESSURE THAT HAD BEEN AIMED HER WAY, PUTTING THAT ON HOLD AND MAKING IT A LITTLE BIT MORE OPTIONAL. SO AS THOSE REGULATIONS AND DISCUSSIONS HAVE PLAYED OUT, WHERE WE STAND TODAY IS NOW EACH DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENT REQUIRED TO SPEAK WITH THEIR BOARD OF EDUCATION ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT THEY WANT THE DISTRICT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE REGIONALIZATION EFFORTS AND TO PASS A RESOLUTION TO THAT EFFECT.
SO WHAT YOU HAVE ON THE AGENDA TONIGHT IS TWO DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS.
AND THEN WE'LL JUST VOTE TO TABLE THE OTHER.
SO I KNOW I'VE SHARED MY PERSPECTIVE JUST VERY SUPER BRIEFLY.
WE HAVE ALREADY SUBMITTED THE DATA.
SO I THINK THAT WAS KIND OF THE BIGGEST LIFT ON THE FRONT END.
WE'RE NOT MANDATED TO DO ANYTHING AS A RESULT OF THAT REGIONALIZATION PLAN, TO THE DEGREE THAT IT IS A COLLABORATIVE OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO SEE IF WE CAN BENEFIT, YOU KNOW, CREATE A SITUATION THAT BE BENEFICIAL TO OUR STUDENTS THROUGH PARTNERSHIPS WITH OTHER DISTRICTS.
I THINK THAT'S ALWAYS A GREAT THING TO DO ANYWAYS.
WE ALREADY DO HAVE A TON OF PARTNERSHIPS.
WE THINK OF THE BEST CONSORTIUM THAT WE HAVE FOR ALL OF OUR TRANSPORTATION, FOR SOME OF OUR SPECIAL EDUCATION PROGRAMS. WE'VE GOT THE BOCES WHO IS THE SPECIALIST AT SHARED SERVICES.
IT IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO COME AROUND AND TO COLLABORATE VOLUNTARILY.
[02:20:10]
ALL THE. YEAH.IT WOULD JUST BE THAT WE'VE SUBMITTED IT, AND THAT'S THE END OF THE PARTICIPATION.
SO I'M GOING TO PROPOSE A MOTION TO ACCEPT NEW YORK STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT REGIONALIZATION PLAN.
AND THE DISCUSSION WAS AS I SHARED.
SO ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS? JUST FOR FOLKS WATCHING AT HOME, WHAT IS REGIONALIZATION? THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION. REGIONALIZATION.
IT WAS AN EMERGENCY REGULATION PASSED BY THE COMMISSIONER.
THAT WAS REQUIRING THAT DISTRICT BOCES DISTRICT SUPERINTENDENTS ASSEMBLE THE DISTRICTS.
THE REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE DISTRICTS WITHIN THEIR REGION ONCE EVERY TEN YEARS AND CRAFT A REGIONALIZATION PLAN, WHICH SPEAKS TO HOW DISTRICTS THE REGION WILL WORK TO COLLABORATE AND CREATE PARTNERSHIPS AND POTENTIALLY SHARING OF SERVICES.
DO YOU THINK THAT WAS THERE ANY DISCUSSION WITH THE LAWYERS ABOUT WHETHER WE OUGHT TO BE SAYING THAT IN OUR RESOLUTION? WE DIDN'T HAVE THAT CONVERSATION.
NO. THIS WAS THE LANGUAGE THAT WAS PROVIDED BY THEM.
AND I THINK I DON'T, I CAN'T SPEAK TO OUR NEIGHBORS SPECIFICALLY, BUT I KNOW SUPERINTENDENTS WERE VERY MIXED AS FAR AS WHETHER THEY WERE ENCOURAGED. THEY WERE RECOMMENDING TO THEIR BOARDS, YOU KNOW, PRO OR CON.
I DO THINK AND I'D HAVE TO DOUBLE CHECK ON THIS.
OKAY. IT WOULD PROBABLY BE ANOTHER JUST A NOTIFICATION TO STATE.
BUT IN AN ADVOCACY MEETING I ATTENDED WITH OTHER DISTRICTS MOSTLY FROM LONG ISLAND, I THINK SOME OF THE CONCERNS WERE ABOUT JUST ABOUT WHAT THEY NEEDED TO DO, ESPECIALLY BECAUSE THEY HAD TO PROVIDE INFORMATION WITHIN A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME.
AND AT THAT POINT IT WAS A REQUIREMENT, NOT A RIGHT KIND OF VOLUNTEER OPTION TO DO IT.
AND SO THEY WERE REALLY UPSET BECAUSE THERE WAS A REQUIREMENT.
AND NOW IT'S CHANGED TO AN OPTIONAL SUBMISSION OR PARTICIPATION.
YEAH. AND I THINK A LOT OF THE LONG ISLAND DISTRICTS, EVEN THE SAME REGULATION.
SOME FOLKS, A LOT OF FOLKS THAT WERE INTERPRETING IT AS IT'S GETTING LATE.
I'M LOSING MY WORDS AS POTENTIALLY OVER HAVING THE POTENTIAL TO OVERRIDE LOCAL BOARD AUTHORITY OVER USING SHARING OF RESOURCES AND PARTICIPATION.
SO BUT I THINK THEY MADE THAT CLEAR IN THE CORRECT AMENDMENTS.
YEAH, THAT THAT IS NOT I'VE HEARD SENATOR, MAYOR SHELLY MAYOR, WHO IS ON THE EDUCATION COMMITTEE IN THE SENATE, SAY THAT SHE WANTS TO SEE LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS RETAIN CONTROL OF THEIR DECISION MAKING PROCESS AND POWER.
BECAUSE IF YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT DISTRICTS IN NORTHWESTERN NEW WESTERN NEW YORK.
I THINK THEY'RE VIEWING REGIONALIZATION IN A VERY DIFFERENT WAY THAN WE DO DOWN HERE OR LONG ISLAND, BECAUSE OF THE PROXIMITY OF OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND THE RESOURCES EACH DISTRICT HAS.
SO IT WOULD BE IT WOULD MEAN VERY DIFFERENT THINGS DEPENDING ON WHERE YOU'RE LOCATED IN THE STATE.
AND SO FOR US DOWN HERE, WE DO HAVE A REALLY ROBUST LIKE SHARING OF RESOURCES ALREADY.
BUT IF YOU LOOK AT DISTRICTS NORTH, REALLY FAR NORTH, THEY DON'T THEY DON'T HAVE THOSE SAME KINDS OF OPTIONS, THE SAME KIND OF CAPABILITIES AND THE SAME KIND OF FUNDING. SO I THINK OUR STATE'S REALLY, REALLY BIG AND TRYING TO HAVE ONE, YOU KNOW, RULE FOR EVERY FIT, EVERYBODY ISN'T POSSIBLE. SO IT'S ENCOURAGING TO HEAR SENATOR MAYER CONTINUE TO SAY THAT SHE REALLY WANTS TO SEE LOCAL DISTRICTS MAINTAIN CONTROL OF DECISION-MAKING PROCESS. THANK YOU.
YEAH. IF NO MORE QUESTIONS, THEN WE NEED A VOTE TO.
[02:25:01]
THE MOTION IS, YOU KNOW, THE VOTE IN HAND IS TO ACCEPT THE NEW YORK STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT REGIONALIZATION PLAN.AYE. ANY OPPOSE? ANY ABSTENTIONS. OKAY, SO THE MOTION PASSES.
[6.2 Motion to Decline the New York State Education Department's Regionalization Plan]
I NEED A MOTION TO TABLE 6.2.THE MOTION TO DECLINE. NEW YORK STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT.
ALL RIGHT. SO MOVING ON TO 6.3.
[6.3 Resolution to Approve Stipulation of Settlement]
[6.4 Motion to Approve Side Letter of Agreement with the Pelham Teachers' Association]
[6.5 Motion to Approve Side Letter of Agreement with the Pelham Teachers' Association]
[6.6 Motion to Dispose of Equipment]
SO CAN WE TAKE THIS AS A 6.6 6.3 TO 6.6 SOME FINANCIAL.SO THERE'S A MOTION TO DISPOSE OF EQUIPMENT.
COULD WE TAKE A MOTION? SO MOVED. I SECOND.
OKAY. ANY QUESTIONS? CONCERNS? OKAY.
AYE. AYE. ANY OPPOSE? ANY ABSTENTIONS? OKAY, SO THE MOTION PASSES.
NOW WE'RE GOING TO DO 6.7 MOTION TO ACCEPT THE DONATION.
[6.7 Motion to Accept a Donation]
SO IT IS RESOLVED THAT UPON RECOMMENDATION OF THE SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS, THE BOARD OF EDUCATION OR THE PELHAM UNION FREE DISTRICT, DOES HEREBY ACCEPT A MONETARY DONATION OF $50 TO THE. AMY, AND I'M SORRY TO PUT YOU IN THIS NAME, JASON GEIGER, SCOTT GEISINGER.THANK YOU. SCHOLARSHIP FUND THAT WOULD GRATITUDE BE BESTOWED UPON HIS DONOR, JEAN COCKCROFT.
OKAY. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. ANY OPPOSE? ANY ABSTENTION. OKAY.
7.0, POLICY MONITORING AND GOVERNANCE.
[7.1 Policy 3291 - Parking (First Reading)]
OKAY, I GUESS I'LL DIVE IN HERE.SO A COUPLE POLICIES UP FOR FIRST READING.
SO WE'RE NOT TAKING ANY ACTION ON THEM TONIGHT.
BUT THE POLICY COMMITTEE CONTINUES TO FIRE ON ALL CYLINDERS HERE UNDER SID'S LEADERSHIP.
SO I'M VERY EXCITED. SO OUR FIRST POLICY IS PARKING POLICY.
THIS ACTUALLY CAME OUT OF DISCUSSIONS WITH OUR LOCAL POLICE CHIEFS AND OUR SAFETY COMMITTEE.
TRYING TO REALLY GET A HANDLE ON TRAFFIC ISSUES AT GLOVER.
AND AS PART OF THAT THEY ASKED THAT WE TAKE A LOOK AT THIS POLICY TO SEE IF WE COULD STRENGTHEN ANY LANGUAGE JUST TO MAKE IT VERY CLEAR THAT THEY HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO TICKET. UM OUR ATTORNEYS ADVISE US WE DON'T NECESSARILY NEED THIS BECAUSE THEY DO HAVE THAT AUTHORITY.
BUT IF THIS MAKES IT A LITTLE MORE CLEAR AND EVIDENT FOR FOLKS, TAKE IT.
ANY QUESTIONS OR ANYTHING TO ADD? NO. NOPE. JUST BE FOREWARNED.
IF IT SAYS NO PARKING, IT REALLY MEANS NO PARKING.
YEAH. IT'S NOT JUST A SUGGESTION.
OKAY. THEN WE HAD ADMINISTRATION OF THE BUDGET.
[7.2 Policy 5140 - Administration of the Budget (First Reading)]
JIM, DO YOU WANT TO JUST DO A QUICK TOUCH ON THAT SINCE IT'S YOUR WORLD? YEAH. REALLY? MINOR CHANGES.AS WE LOOK AT THINGS BASED ON RECOMMENDATIONS FROM OUR FROM OUR POLICY SERVICE.
THAT'S ADDED TO THE BOTTOM OF IT.
YEAH. AND THIS WAS ONE THAT CAME UP ON THE AUDIT AS ONE TO UPDATE.
SO ANY QUESTIONS THERE? OKAY. THOSE ARE VERY MINOR ONES.
[7.3 Policy 6130 - Evaluation of Personnel (First Reading)]
DOCTOR FITZGERALD DO YOU WANT TO MENTION ANY.JUST SPEAK TO THE CHANGES THAT WERE THERE.
AND WE DO RECOGNIZE TO THE LAW AROUND APPR HAS CHANGED.
AND WE'RE JUST ON THE CUSP OF STARTING TO THINK ABOUT WHAT WE WANT THAT TO LOOK LIKE.
THAT DOES THAT NEED TO NEED TO BE NEGOTIATED WITH COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNITS? BUT THIS SHOULD STILL STAND.
THIS POLICY SHOULD STILL STAND REGARDLESS OF THOSE CHANGES.
NO, NO, WE DON'T NEED TO DO ANY MOTION.
SO WE'LL BRING THOSE BACK NEXT TIME FOR SECOND READING.
[02:30:02]
SO CAN I JUST SAY THANK YOU SID.YOU ARE LIKE GOING THROUGH THAT POLICY BOOK.
I MEAN, IT'S REALLY MOSTLY THE ADMINISTRATIVE TEAM THAT'S BEEN DOING THE HEAVY LIFTING.
I WAS GOING TO SAY, I'M GLAD WE'RE NOT PAYING YOU BY THE HOUR.
[8.1 Motion to Approve Schedule C - Non-Instructional]
MOTION TO APPROVE SCHEDULE C AND INSTRUCTIONAL.SORRY. A COUPLE OF RESIGNATIONS, THAT'S ALL.
ANY OPPOSED? ANY ABSTENTIONS? OKAY. MOVING ON TO NINE.
[9.1 Motion to Approve Schedule D - Committee on Special Education (Confidential)]
PUPIL 9.1.MOTION TO APPROVE, SCHEDULE D, COMMITTEE ON SPECIAL EDUCATION.
ALL RIGHT. NOW WE'RE MOVING ON TO NEW BUSINESS.
ANY NEW BUSINESS? I THINK WE'VE COVERED PLENTY FOR TONIGHT, BUT THAT'S JUST ME.
MOVING ON TO 11.1 COMMUNICATIONS COMING FROM THE PUBLIC.
AGAIN I KNOW EVERYBODY'S HOPEFULLY NICE AND SAFE AND WARM AT HOME WATCHING US ON YOUTUBE OF COURSE.
DO I HAVE A MOTION TO ADJOURN? SO MOVED. SECOND.
THANK YOU. AND THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO CONDUCT THE MEETING ON BEHALF OF JACKIE.
THANK YOU ALL. IT'S A GREAT CONVERSATION.
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.